Cosmo DiNardo; suspected serial killer

| July 14, 2017

Four men went missing last week and Cosmo DiNardo is their suspected killer according to the Tribunist. The missing men are Jimi Tar Patrick, 19, Dean Finocchiaro, 19, Mark Sturgis, 22, and Tom Meo, 21. They were last seen on July 7th. DiNardo became a suspect when he tried to sell a car belonging to one of his victims for $500.

Finocchiaro’s body was discovered on DiNardo’s parents’ property buried in a hole twelve feet deep.

DiNardo has been diagnosed with schizophrenia which prevents him from purchasing weapons, however, he is well known throughout his community as someone that can get you whatever gun you need. In fact, he was arrested on weapons charges in February, but the local magistrate dismissed those charges late last month…for some reason – just weeks before his four victims disappeared.

From Philly.com;

Eric Beitz, 20, of Bensalem, said Wednesday that he and his friends had hung out often in recent weeks with Cosmo DiNardo, and said DiNardo came off as agreeable on the surface but routinely sold firearms, spoke about killing people, and seemed to have “ulterior motives.”

“I can tell you on multiple different occasions, on multiple different accounts, from multiple different people, including myself – Cosmo has spoken about weird things like killing people and having people killed,” Beitz said. “Everybody you talk to about this guy, you hear he’s mentally unstable.”

Yet a local magistrate dismissed weapons charges against him. DiNardo would pop hot on a NICS check but he was buying and selling guns illegally without a background check. They missed their chance to lock his ass up last month, but I guess they felt sorry for him and let him loose.

Beitz recalled DiNardo’s offering to sell another friend a shotgun at their first meeting. He said that DiNardo had bragged about having someone killed because of a dispute over $800, and that DiNardo said he only gave his phone number out to “people who kill people.”

He sold “rifles, shotguns, handguns… assault rifles. Whatever he could get his hands on. He would kind of brag about it, too,” Beitz said. He said DiNardo routinely sent them photos of himself posing with guns.

According to another Philly.com link DiNardo was arrested earlier this week on the charge that was dropped last month;

DiNardo was originally arrested for allegedly possessing a shotgun and ammunition he was not permitted to have because he had a “mental illness” and had been involuntarily committed to an inpatient treatment facility, according to a criminal complaint filed in February.

Yeah, the government will protect us if we all give up our guns.

UPDATES: Inside Edition reports that DiNardo confessed to the murders in exchange for taking the death penalty off the table. His lawyer says that DiNardo “feels deep remorse” for the murders. Other remains were found late yesterday in his 12-foot pit.

Fox News reports that a second “person of interest” is in custody.

The Washington Post says Sean M. Kratz was charged with three counts of homicide in the case, as DiNardo’s accomplice.

Category: Guns

27 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Brown Neck Gaitor

Suspected hell, he confessed last night according to both the DA and his defense attorney.

Had they not dropped the charges and had they actually bothered to arrested him the second time when the charges were refiled in June, these 4 guys would very likely be alive.

Hey PA, the hole is already dug, what ya waiting for?

d

If he confessed he gets promoted to “alleged”

Dapandico

Not a homosexual serial killer?

Ex-PH2

But he looks like such a nice guy….

Sonny's Mom

Ex-Ph2: bears a striking resemblance to David Berkowitz, the “Son of Sam” killer, IMO.

OWB

Seems like more families should be filing lawsuits against various agencies, bureaucrats, and pols for failure to enforce the law. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Such cases would not go anywhere, but there must be some negative publicity value in having the discussion.

In general terms, it’s disgusting to observe crap like this. It must be beyond horrible to see a loved one killed as a direct result of folks being paid to enforce our laws willfully failing to do so.

Toasty Coastie

Wonder if the prosecutors or judges are related to that bitch that let the cop killer go. Would explain why this murderer wasn’t charged.

Eden

Daddy has lots of money and is a big shot in the area. He’s the one who bailed this loser out of jail before the second set of charges was filed and he was arrested again.

OldManchu

I bet he would feel even more remorse if they let him spend the night in the 12 foot joke with his handy work.

A Proud Infidel®™

Gee whiz, doesn’t shit like this give one a really warm fuckin’ fuzzy feeling of confidence in our criminal justice system, WTF good are any laws when they aren’t enforced? I wonder if his big bucks Daddy has any remorse at all about the people his boy murdered?

Fyrfighter

In the Philly area, with a last name like DiNardo, it’s not at all out of the realm of possibility that daddy got his big bucks as part of the mob… I don’t have any idea if he has or not, but there is plenty of that going on in that area..

the_dude

Why do we keep taking the death penalty off the table? the world would be better off with less of these unstable ass hats around.

Stop using our tax dollars to feed them and take care of them.

A Proud Infidel®™

Given the expense of the seemingly endless appeals, it’s often cheaper to lock them up for life sans parole than it is to put the damn goblins to death,

Deplorable B Woodman

How a out paying a prison lifer to off the guy once he’s in? Best of both worlds.

Graybeard

The magistrate may have the joy of a “wrongful death” lawsuit or something similar slapped against them.

If the victims included one of my kids after a judge let him off the hook, I’d be making all the negative publicity I could for that judge.

Commissar

Pretty sure judges have immunity from responsibility or liability for things like this.

Unless he took a bribe.

David

Correction on your phrasing: selling guns privately without a background check is the norm. Doing so for revenue as an unlicensed dealer is illegal. Private sales do not require a background check, dealer sales do. Don’t add fuel to the ‘universal background check/universal registration’ fire.

A Proud Infidel®™

He was already prohibited by law from possessing firearms and ammunition but he was selling them anyway, why not just enforce existing laws?

d

Not sure he was actually prohibited by law… prior charges seem to have all either been dropped or not prosecuted. If he had a clean record – well, see my comment above.

Rock

It’s not charges that wouldnof prevented him from purchasing a weapon from a dealer, it’s the fact that he had an involuntary psychiatric hospitalization on his record.

I regretfully have one as well, during a bad time in my life that was fixed by the VA… I can’t purchase a weapon anymore either. It’s on the NICS database. It even shows up when I get pulled over for a traffic ticket…

IDC SARC

psychiatric reporting from the states to NICS is voluntary, yours may have only been entered because of the federal involvement.

Many similarly hospitalized (not in a federal facility)patients do not get entered into NICS.

The Other Whitey

Once again we see gun laws doing no good whatsoever, with authorities not bothering to enforce them. If “everybody knew” what this asshole was into before he killed anybody, then the local cops knew, too. He was violating all kinds of existing laws and was clearly anything but harmless. Yet nothing happened! But some bleeding-heart will come out saying how a new, stricter law will fix this.

bg2

According to this article, DiNardo and Kratz are cousins: http://www.cnn.com/2017/07/14/us/missing-pennsylvania-men-charges/index.html

Commissar

He is a member of one of the wealthiest and most connected families in is state.

Not so surprising the weapons charges were dropped.

HMC Ret

None of this would have happened if there had been only one more laws. Either that or enforce existing laws.

I’m most impressed with the 12 foot hole in the ground. That’s an impressive hole, folks. That would have been an impressive challenge to a cadaver dog.