New Zealand loses first ship since WWII

| October 7, 2024

HMNZS Manawanui goin’ down

News sources are reporting that HMNZS Manawanui has run around, caught fire, and sunk off Samoa. Whoopies. Sounds like all the crew and passengers are safe though. This is the first naval vessel lost for the small South Pacific nation since the Second World War.

Yahoo! News has the story;

A Royal New Zealand Navy ship, HMNZS Manawanui, has run aground and sunk off Samoa while carrying out a tropical reef survey, but all 75 crew and passengers on board have been reported safe ashore.

On Sunday, the New Zealand Defence Force said that the Manawanui, the NZ navy’s specialist dive and hydrographic vessel, ran aground near the southern coast of Samoa’s main island of Upolu on Saturday night as its crew were making the survey at the island nation.

Tanuvasa Petone, the Samoa fire commissioner, said that the ship caught fire and sank on Sunday morning after a successful rescue, NZ Radio reported. Three on board needed hospital treatment, he said.

“They’re all on land. They are safe and sound apart from just a few individuals that… have some minor injuries, and so we treated them at the site and transferred to them to the hospital.”

The cause of the grounding was unknown and would need further investigation, the Defence Force said. The vessel later capsized and was below the surface by 9am local time on Sunday, it said.

It was “working with authorities to understand the implications and minimise the environmental impacts”.

Rear-Adml Garin Golding, the Chief of Navy, told a press conference in Auckland that a plane would leave for Samoa on Sunday to bring the rescued crew and passengers back to New Zealand.

He said that some of those rescued had suffered minor injuries, including from walking across a reef.

Judith Collins, the New Zealand defence minister, described the grounding as a “really challenging for everybody on board.”

Ms Collins told the press conference: “I know that what has happened is going to take quite a bit of time to process.

“I look forward to pinpointing the cause so that we can learn from it and avoid a repeat,” she said, adding that an immediate focus was to salvage “what is left” of the vessel.

Video and photos published on local media showed the Manawanui, which cost the country’s government 103 million New Zealand dollars (£48.2 million) in 2018, listing heavily and with plumes of thick grey smoke rising.

Rescue operations were coordinated by Samoan emergency services and Australian Defence Force personnel with the assistance of the New Zealand rescue centre, according to a statement from Samoa Police, Prison and Corrections Service posted on Facebook.

The Manawanui has conducted a range of specialist diving, salvage and survey tasks around New Zealand and across the South West Pacific.

New Zealand’s Navy is already working at reduced capacity with three of its nine ships idle due to personnel shortage.

The King is due to visit Samoa later this month for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, which starts on Oct 21.

Now, in some circles there has been talk about the ship’s skipper. Normally running around and sinking a ship is ignominious enough for a naval captain, but this one took command to some celebration as the first lesbian ship captain for the Royal New Zealand Navy in 2022. It’s especially ironic that her ship is a salvage vessel.

Commander Yvonne Gray, RNZN

Yorkshire woman takes command of Royal New Zealand Navy Ship

Today, Commander Gray took the helm of the RNZN’s dive, hydrographic and salvage vessel HMNZS Manawanui, based at Devonport Naval Base in Auckland. Manawanui is M?ori for ‘steadfast’ or ‘big heart’.

It is her first ship command in a naval career that started in the United Kingdom in 1993 as a warfare officer. Her service as a warfare officer ranged from working on aircraft carriers to frigates and mine hunters.

In 2012, Commander Gray and her wife Sharon moved to New Zealand after falling in love with the country during a campervan holiday.

“The most obvious thing to do was join the Royal New Zealand Navy,” she said.

As the Commanding Officer of the RNZN’s Mine Counter Measures Team she participated in activities all over the world, and her role in maritime evaluation has seen her help ‘work up’ ships and crews to peak efficiency.

She said her eyes lit up at the thought of taking command of Manawanui, which entered service with the Royal New Zealand Navy three years ago.

“Sure, for a lot of warfare officers, that’s the pinnacle of their career to get to ‘drive’ a ship. I prefer to think of my career as a ridgeline, sometimes the view is good and sometimes it is better,” said Commander Gray.

A former student of Bilton Grange Primary School and Harrogate Granby High School, she obtained a Bachelor of Education (Honours) at the University of Lancaster but teaching jobs were scarce in Yorkshire at the time.

Commander Gray discovered the Navy while spending her university holidays leading outdoor activities at a Sea Cadet facility in the Lake District.

“I worked with a lot of Navy people and there was something about their way which appealed to me.”

She signed up for an eight-year commission with the Royal Navy.

“The idea was at the end of eight years you got £23,000. I was really into cooking at the time and I thought do eight years, get £23,000, open my own restaurant.”

But several years in, she knew the Navy life was for her.

“I was really enjoying myself. I could see it was an organisation where I fitted well.”

Her campervan passion is still going strong, but the call of the sea is always there too. Commander Gray returned to the RNZN earlier this year after heading off in late 2019 on a 57,000-kilometre road trip around Australia with Sharon and their dog Dennis.

I’ll reserve judgement on her gender and/or sexuality playing any role in this accident until the requisite inquests are completed.

Category: Breaking News, Kiwis, Navy

58 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
KoB

Maybe the Good Captain was a submariner at heart…after all, her wife was constantly telling her to DIVE…DIVE…DIVE!

I’ll see myself out.

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

NZ only has 7 ships (now)
So…. Captain Ellen Degenerate here singlehandedly sunk over 12% of the Kiwi Navy.
I wonder if China will give her a medal?

Anonymous

Like Abe Simpson and his Iron Cross:

Last edited 2 months ago by Anonymous
E. Conboy

Editor: I did not intend to thumb up. Please consider deleting. Tx.

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

I guess lesbians and seamen don’t mix.

Odie

I wonder if the fish tossed her back for stinking up the water😏

jeff LPH 3 63-66

RIMSHOT

Anonymous

Let’s hear it for DEI “firsts” again! /sarc

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

Maybe her surface ship identifies as Trans-Submarine?

2banana

DEI to its inevitable logical conclusion.

Anonymous

To err is human, but to really f*ck things up requires a DEI hire.

Odie

I wonder if she will be promoted for reasons.

Anonymous

F*ck up and move up…

2banana

And the “Captain” has a wife.

Checking boxes.

SFC D

KoB, RCAF, you’re both in timeout. Do you two dickweeds have any idea how bad it hurts when you laugh so hard that you try to spew chicken and rice through your sinuses?

I hate you both.

Hack Stone

Read the fine print in the Terms of Service. It explicitly states that This Ain’t Hell is not responsible for any damage to cellphones, computer monitors, tablets and exploding pagers as a result of not heeding the Preemptive Level IV Spew Alerts. Any claims for compensation must be settled via arbitration, with the aggrieved party being represented by Daniel Bernath, Esquire.

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

Being represented by ‘ Bansai ‘ Bernath would be a major PITA.
I’m doubtful most judges would allow a Ouija Board in their courtrooms.

Army-Air Force Guy

Lori Benton’s probably available.

11B-Mailclerk

Via “dead letter”?

KoB

Jus’ sayin’…

comment image

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

I apologize, I will send you a netti pot for Thanksgiving.
Doesn’t Captain Coochkisser remind you of a bucktooth Pat, from SNL?
My first posting was Victoria, BC. Coming from a small, rural town where most folks were Dutch Reform farmers, it was quite the culture shock.
I was SO disappointed to learn that most lesbians look nothing like the ones in the ‘movies’ and mags. 🤣

USMC Steve

Is flannel often involved?

A Proud Infidel®™

I always thought that Lesbians nearly all looked alike because they’re always rubbing off on each other!

Anonymous

Nuttin’ like the Bob Dole erectile dysfunction ad… I was drinking coffee when I saw it and should’t have been (serious spew):

Forest Bondurant

Rhetorical question:

What’s the punishment for hazarding a ship in the New Zealand Navy or creating an environmental disaster?

In the U.S., hazarding a ship or vessel is covered under UCMJ Article 110.

Fyrfighter

DEI trumps UCMJ

Forest Bondurant

I almost forgot. Thanks.

E. Conboy

Apparently.

AW1Ed

Conducting a reef survey? Found one.

Hack Stone

Survey says… Oh shit!!!

Hack Stone

Sonar Technician: Captain, it appears that the ship is about to collide with a reef.

Captain Gray: Well, we are on a reef mapping mission, only one way to find out. Full speed ahead, and damn the ecosystem!

Hack Stone

Let’s see if this link displays the video.

ChipNASA

Sounds……

Familar….

Hack Stone

Coincidentally, Hack Stone just consumed the last to kiwis that Rosetta Stone purchased from Aldi.

Hack Stone

Any truth to the rumor that the ship was using navigation software procured from a proud but humble woman owned business formerly located on Wilson Drive in Bethesda Maryland?

KoB

Navigating by Magic 8 Ball?

Hack Stone

Captain Gray: Chief, do you expect a successful mission?

CPO Outback: Let me check the Magic 8-Ball, Skipper. Magic 8-Ball says….

IMG_1929
rgr769

Maybe she was navigating by iPad, using the Bernathian technique.

President Elect Toxic Deplorable Racist SAH Neande

Did she make sure she had enough fuel before taking off?

Hack Stone

And with that accomplishment, she was named an Honorary Chief Petty Officer by the Disbarred Lawers Association.

Army-Air Force Guy

Complete with free photoshop software!

SFC D

Sure does suck when a reef just pops up out of nowhere and wrecks your boat.

jeff LPH 3 63-66

First thought was that the ship was on a dependents cruise hence the passengers until I read the article. Maybe she had the ship do a chinese landing to berth alongside the reef but didn’t give the ship enough room to complete the turn. We berthed in La Pallice France for liberty call after Op Steelpike in 1964 and tied up to a camel. On my watch, I had to take a water reading down in the seabag locker and going down the ladder I stepped into sea water. Went to the Quarter deck and mentioned it to one of the watch standers who notified R Div. And after pumping out the water, the hole was fixed. A large bolt was sticking out of the steel band that held the camel together and while we were there, the bolt bored a hole on the side of the rocking ship.

Hack Stone

For those of us with limited nautical verbiage knowledge, what is a “camel” in the context of your post? Last year when Hack was crossing the Atlantic to the UK, he finally got to Dunkirk while in flight. He was quite confused when the British officers kept speaking of “moles”, until Hack connected the dots and figured out that mole is interchangeable with dock.

Grunt

I think it has something to do with the poop deck.

Hack Stone

Since you brought it up…

jeff LPH 3 63-66

A camel is a wooden floating platform that a ship will dock/berth against when there is no pier to dockberth against

Hack Stone

So, is that the same as mole? Sounds the same, based off of my one viewing of Dunkirk.

JustALurkinAround

First thing you do when something starts leaking is to jam your fingers in the dyke.

You learn that as a kid.

BlueCord Dad

I see what you did there..🤣

USMC Steve

Does their navy, such as it is, shitcan ship skippers that ground their vessels?

Forest Bondurant

Not lesbian captains of the DEI persuasion. Doing so would be misogynistic or something

Hack Stone

Captain Gray was the victim of a vast right reef conspiracy.

Charles

So the Captain may have gone down ON her ship, but did not go down WITH her ship?

SFC D

She said something about a little man in a boat but it was muffled

A Proud Infidel®™

A Skipper with a degree in Education? Hmm, maybe a token?

Anonymous

Just in… NZ says it’s misogynistic/homophobic to blame the captain when it’s the fault of their ships being in such poor condition instead:
https://apnews.com/article/zealand-navy-ship-sexism-woman-commander-samoa-778b42dcefe5adc252673fd16cf41372

Last edited 2 months ago by Anonymous