Holding Onto Hallowed Ground in Hawaii

| January 13, 2014

An old paratrooper, with whom I once served, sent me a heads up on a situation from which I am geographically distanced, but as a one-time combat infantryman in the far-western Pacific, find close to my heart. On the Hawaiian island of Oahu is one of the most beautiful resting places of American war dead to be found anywhere in the world. I know this because I have been there and gazed out over the green expanse of the Punchbowl and felt the same sense of awed reverence as when I have visited my Vietnam Wall, the World War II Memorial, and the Korean War Memorial in Washington. The Punchbowl is the Arlington Cemetery of the Pacific and like all those other sacred sites the Punchbowl is hallowed ground, infused with the sacrifice of the tens of thousands buried there who gave their all in service to this nation. That lush green resting place in paradise is a fitting tribute to that long blue, green, and khaki line of sailors, soldiers, and marines who died fighting on, over and even under those coral seas and on those endless deadly islands of the Pacific.

The conventional wisdom has been for years that the Punchbowl, due to its terrain limitations, is at full capacity and incapable of accepting new burials. I heard that decades ago, when I was there, and believed it until I received an email from someone well-attuned to the POW/MIA scene, Bill Bell, a man whom I served with in the 101st at Fort Campbell back in the early sixties. Bill went on, after a stint in Special Forces, to become the lead military investigator in the Vietnam POW/MIA issue and author of a book describing those events. While long ago retired from active duty, he remains energetic in that honorable pursuit of what is right, just, and dutiful in bringing home our honored dead from foreign battlefields.

But this is not about Bill; it’s about the Punchbowl. While it has long been thought to be filled to capacity, a strange thing is happening due to the residual effects of the program that Bill helped initiate. Formerly unidentified remains interred in the Punchbowl now are being identified and removed for reburial in their mainland home communities. That presents a unique opportunity for the reburial of former sons of Hawaii who served in units such as the fabled 442d Regimental Combat Team, a unit primarily comprised of Nisei, loyal Japanese Americans, many from Hawaii, who served with exemplary distinction in the European Theater in WWII. I can’t think of anything more justifiable than that any sons of Hawaii, who have fallen in service to their island and their mainland nation, whether in WWII, Korea, Vietnam, or the Middle Eastern wars, should find their final resting place in that sacred green Punchbowl.

But surprise, surprise; according to this article, the federal bureaucracy has been hiding the information that disinterments due to remains identification have created available burial sites for those, who more than any other, are entitled to be buried there. You would think this is an issue to be taken up by the Hawaii media and their leftist Democrat government, but since they tend to march in lockstep with the all too often anti-military Obama administration, lots of luck there. It makes me wonder, in light of the rumors that he intends to retire to Hawaii, is our narcissistic CinC planning ahead a few decades, concerned about saving a large, presidential burial plot in the Punchbowl, complete with the space necessary for an outsized monument to mark his own highly regarded remains? That may sound a bit out there to some of you but when you consider this president’s self-centeredness; it isn’t out there that far. Presidents do tend to think in grand terms; for a narcissist president make that grandiose. So, if his goal is retirement in Hawaii then burial in the Arlington of the Pacific could be an attractive finale; thus the space saving.

From this old sergeant’s point of view, the man who tried to fundamentally change the nation those Punchbowl warriors fought to preserve is not fit to rest among them. I say bury him in Southside Chicago where removing the spray-painted gangsta graffiti from his tomb and picking up the litter will be required daily.That seems altogether more fitting, since that was Chicago that foisted him on a well-intentioned but naively unsuspecting nation. Chicago made him… let Chicago keep him… forever.

Crossposted at American Thinker

Category: Support the troops

19 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ChipNASA

I disagree Poetrooper.
As Green Thumb would say, A Turd like that belongs in a Punchbowl. Where else more fitting?
Maybe the world’s largest toilet in Columbus, Indiana?

CC Senor

“Chicago that foisted him on a well-intentioned but naively unsuspecting nation. Chicago made him… let Chicago keep him… forever.”

Ooh, that’s cold…..but fitting.

2/17 Air Cav

According to the Stars and Stripes article, there is no issue with our Fallen being buried in any otherwise “closed” cemetery, including the Punchbowl. The closures apply to us Veterans. What’s more, there have been 63 full-casket sites created by the later-identified occupants of those sites and funeral homes in Hawaii were informed of their availability. Neither of these points did I see in the post. That obama stuff I like, however implausible it may be. For one, it would take multiple vacancies (maybe 30 or 40), all concentrated together, to accomodate his tomb. For another, such a site would not be sufficiently grand for him. He’ll need something approximating the Jefferson or Lincoln Memorials. Me, I’d like to see him buried either in Red Square or, failing that, Kenya.

MGySgtRet.

…or failing that, wherever the fuck it is that Osama Bin Ladens remains ended up…..

ChipNASA

@ 2/17…How about drop him in a volcano?

OWB

Was only there once, and it was decades ago. The Punchbowl does indeed evoke the same feelings as those at the Wall.

The thought of the traitor in chief being buried in such hallowed ground is quite disturbing. Surely there is a lava flow somewhere among the islands that would be a more suitable final resting spot.

Combat Historian

I grew up in Hawaii, but have no intention to ever move back to that leftard socialist welfare “paradise”. The locals have turned the place into a garbage dump, and they are joined daily by legions of mainlanders who fly to Hawaii just to live homeless on the beaches, enjoy the meth, and buy pakalolo and ice with their generous state welfare handouts. Enjoy the suck, Hawaii…

TheCloser

Red Square?

Just An Old Dog

Don’t think it’s plausible to even think about where they are going to with that jackass. If there is an afterlife centered around all the fallen vets there Obama could fit in as a shine boy in the barracks, or one of the guys who flips burgers at the slop chute.

2/17 Air Cav

@8. Yes, Red Square.

The Other Whitey

Can’t say I’d be surprised if it turns out that the Glorious Leader plans on having graves at The Punchbowl disinterred to make room for his grand mausoleum or whatever monstrosity he plans on being buried in.

Now maybe I’m wrong, but I wouldn’t be surprised. Disgusted, but not surprised.

Green Thumb

Punchbowl is a very beautiful and moving place.

SFC D

I have a punchbowl plan for the Obama.
1-cremation following a death of natural causes.
2-cremains placed in 1 each discounted punchbowl found in discount stores such as Marshall’s, kohls, etc.
3-cremains & punchbowl placed in most convenient dumpster.

MustangCryppie

@7 I’m with you Combat Historian. I was a beat cop with HPD on the West Coast. Waianae, Nanakuli, Ewa Beach. All of what you said is true. Unfortunately.

NHSparky

@14…all true even when I was there, sad to say.

Green Thumb

@1.

Or Columbus, Ga.

Twist

@1: I live close to there, please keep him out of my area.

Stacy0311

maybe to appease the Taliban, we could give him the Osama bin Laden special.

Historian

Interesting discussion.

As one who has walked past each of the Unidentified Remains section of the Punchbowl behind the main administration building, I have a small number of observations.

The removal of remains has indeed opened up burial plots.

However, the Unknowns are closely spaced in an area where only small flat markers are located.

The Korean War Unknown area is a distinct location with no upright headstones or other specific name markers the last time I was there some years ago. I doubt it has changed much.

So to initiate burials in the open plots, this would mean placing headstones among a sea of Unknowns. It is above my pay grade to determine if this would detract from the solemn nature of the special area where the Unknowns are buried.

For me, to walk along each row in turn was a very special experience. To know that I would later have a small part in the identification of some of the remains has left a lasting impression of that walk among the Unknowns.