An Interesting Bit of US Military History
Poke around on the Internet enough, and you learn new things. Sometimes you even learn something useful. (smile)
We often hear people refer to the Purple Heart as the US military’s “oldest decoration”. It turns out that statement is only partially true.
While the Purple Heart is the oldest US military decoration still in use, the Purple Heart was not the first US military decoration or medal awarded to members of the Continental Army. It was also not the first awarded to recognize exceptional performance of duty.
The Purple Heart was first awarded in 1782 as the “Badge of Military Merit”. However, a number of other US medals were authorized by the Continental Congress, struck, and awarded that predate the Purple Heart. Most of these do not appear to qualify as military decorations per se; rather, they were awarded to single individuals, had varying criteria, and had varying designs. They also appear to have been without a means of suspension to allow them to be worn with a uniform or civilian clothing; they were more like large coins than military decorations. In short, these medals appear to have been commemorative medals issued as a Congressional “thank you” to specific individuals by name (indeed, on several the individual being honored was portrayed), but not intended to be worn by the recipient as a military decoration.
However, one medal authorized by the Continental Congress exists that predates the Badge of Military Merit and which does appear to qualify as a military decoration. That medal has a standard design, had specific criteria, and was awarded to multiple individuals for exceptional performance of duty. This medal also has a suspension ring – and was thus clearly intended to be worn by the individual. That decoration is the Fidelity Medallion, authorized by act of the Congressional Congress and awarded in 1780 – two years before the Badge of Military Merit.
The Fidelity Medallion (AKA the “Andre Capture Medallion”)
The Fidelity Medallion was awarded to three enlisted personnel of the Continental Army, all members of the New York militia: Privates John Paulding, Isaac Van Wart, and David Williams. They received this award for capturing Major John Andre – the British recruiter, “handler”, and courier for US traitor and spy Benedict Arnold. For this reason the Fidelity Medallion is sometimes called the “Andre Capture Medallion”.
Since it was authorized by the Continental Congress for exceptional performance in connection with a specific act, only those three Fidelity Medallions were awarded. It was never awarded again and is now considered obsolete. However, it does appear to meet the criteria of a military decoration awarded for exceptional performance of duty. And it predates the Badge of Military Merit – the forerunner of today’s Purple Heart – by roughly two years.
Even though the above qualifies as trivia, IMO this info is interesting as US military history. And it might not be completely useless trivia, either. Knowing it might even allow you to win a libation or two in a friendly wager while socializing. (smile)
Category: Historical
Great Hondo…now how long will it before a poser shows up with one now that you revealed that?
Nice catch Hondo, very interesting indeed. Although, the name “Badge of Military Merit” confuses me, I don’t see anything particularly meritorious about forgetting to duck.
Don Carl: the original criteria for the Revolutionary War-era Badge of Military Merit were actually more like the criteria for today’s Medal of Honor than today’s Purple Heart. The stories of the 3 recipients of the Badge of Military Merit are briefly detailed in the first link above.
The Badge of Military Merit was essentially “repurposed” when the old “wound chevron” was done away with and replaced with today’s Purple Heart.
I remember reading “The Red Badge Of Courage” in school.
I think we will all need to be watching for Soup Sandwich to be sporting the lost fourth medal that was secretly awarded in a midnight ceremony while the records were silmultaneously lost in the “fire”.
Hondo-this is interesting, FYI HRC has some stats for the Certificate of Merit and Badge of Military Merit for the Revolution and Mexican war at https://www.hrc.army.mil/TAGD/Awards%20and%20Decorations%20Statistics%20by%20Conflict
One of the few NCO Board questions I always remember, the first individual medal awarded to NCOs, purple heart.
By the way Dana, there won’t be any records because over time they “disintegrated” for the guy who got this before he was even born.
Have we ever gotten the “oh I got these medals in my past life, that’s why I can wear them now…” story before?
Proud to say that my hometown of Tarrytown, New York was the scene of Andre’s capture. The three who captured him were quite the “rock stars” in post-Revolutionary War America.
I’m pretty sure that they were the only ones awarded the “Fidelity Medallion.” Could be wrong though. Wouldn’t be the first time, nor the last.
Whoops! Should have read the WHOLE entry! See now that I was right about only three being awarded the Fidelity Medallion. Guess I was just so excited to see it highlighted!
Good stuff, Hondo.
@ #7: Oh! That past life idea would cover a whole lot of potential pretty medals as well as those from any country in the world. But please don’t be giving the fakers any ideas!! 😉
68W58: the Certificate of Merit is another little-known and interesting obsolete Army decoration. Time permitting, I’ll try to write up and post a short article about it one day soon.
Hondo I found this link on Wiki about the Certificate Of Merit. Is it the same one you referred to? It was pretty interesting.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_Merit_Medal
Sorry if I jumped in the middle of your road. Apologies if needed.
I also found this on the Badge Of Military Merit. I think the oldest of the old.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Badge_of_Military_Merit
Sparks: that’s part of what I’ll likely write up regarding the Certificate of Merit if/when I can find the time to do so. There’s some additional that goes with it if I can find it again.
The Badge of Military Merit is the forerunner of today’s Purple Heart, and was instituted in 1782. However, the Fidelity Medallion is about 2 years older. Both were awarded for exceptional performance of assigned duties. Each was awarded only to enlisted soldiers, and each was awarded precisely 3 times to recognize exceptional performance during the Revolutionary War.
The Fidelity Medallion was never awarded again after the initial three. The Badge of Military Merit was also never awarded again per se.
Frankly, we’d probably have forgotten both had the Badge of Military Merit not been resurrected as today’s Purple Heart on the 200th anniversary of Washinton’s birth. Army Chief of Staff GEN (later GA) Douglas MacArthur was instrumental in getting the decoration revived. Currently, the Purple Heart is used for a totally different purpose (recognition of combat wounds) than was its predecessor.
This discussion actually dovetails nicely with another interesting historical bit regarding recognition for combat wounds. Check TAH tomorrow morning. (smile)
You might find something on this at the Society of the Cincinnati on Mass Ave. in DC. It’s the society George Washington and other Continental Army officers started to preserve and document the revolutionary values and to explain for history why they fought. There are archives there with journals, letters and other writings by Washington and his officers. It’s a stunning building, with displays of rare militaria.
There was also a French chapter headed by Gen. Lafayette and Maj. L’Enfant. Membership was limited to those who actually fought in the Revolutionary War, and is hereditary now, passed down through the eldest son of each generation.
Really Sparks I totally share…. Love the job
of the exposing of these phony’s there all turds..
[…] tip to Sparks’ comment here regarding the Red Badge of Courage for prompting the research that led to me finding this little […]