Daylight Saving Time, Should we Keep It?

| March 8, 2019

©1996 Image Club Graphics
A division of Adobe Systems Incorporated
This file is also available in high resolution TIFF and low resolution PICT formats

On Sunday morning, clocks advance an hour in states that observe Daylight Saving Time.  Come Monday, many are going to feel like they are in two worlds. On one hand, it would feel like they got up and reported to work an hour earlier. On the other hand, the watch will say one thing, but daylight would look like something else.

There are some who want to get rid of it altogether. Others want to keep it. What do you think? Keep it or get rid of it?

Category: Society

35 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ex-PH2

Keep it. It might need a new home some day. It whines when you leave it, you know.

Veritas Omnia Vincit

According to the History Channel: Germany was the first country to enact daylight saving time. It took World War I for Willett’s dream to come true, but on April 30, 1916, Germany embraced daylight saving time to conserve electricity. (He may have been horrified to learn that Britain’s wartime enemy followed his recommendations before his homeland.) Weeks later, the United Kingdom followed suit and introduced “summer time.” Daylight saving time in the United States was not intended to benefit farmers, as many people think. Contrary to popular belief, American farmers did not lobby for daylight saving to have more time to work in the fields; in fact, the agriculture industry was deeply opposed to the time switch when it was first implemented on March 31, 1918, as a wartime measure. The sun, not the clock, dictated farmers’ schedules, so daylight saving was very disruptive. Farmers had to wait an extra hour for dew to evaporate to harvest hay, hired hands worked less since they still left at the same time for dinner and cows weren’t ready to be milked an hour earlier to meet shipping schedules. Agrarian interests led the fight for the 1919 repeal of national daylight saving time, which passed after Congress voted to override President Woodrow Wilson’s veto. Rather than rural interests, it has been urban entities such as retail outlets and recreational businesses that have championed daylight saving over the decades. For decades, daylight saving in the United States was a confounding patchwork of local practices. After the national repeal in 1919, some states and cities, including New York City and Chicago, continued to shift their clocks. National daylight saving time returned during World War II, but after its repeal three weeks after war’s end the confusing hodgepodge resumed. States and localities could start and end daylight saving whenever they pleased, a system that Time magazine (an aptly named source) described in 1963 as “a chaos of clocks.” In 1965 there were 23 different pairs of start and end dates in Iowa alone, and St. Paul, Minnesota, even began daylight saving two weeks before its twin… Read more »

Toxic Deplorable B Woodman

DITCH IT!!!
I’ve lived in the two states that DON’T do the DST switch, and thoroughly loved it.
Anytime I do the DST switch, spring and fall, it throws my wake/sleep cycle into a spin for a month.
There is no reason to have had it then, and even less reason to have it now.
DITCH THE DST!!

cc senor

Right. When I was a young soldier I didn’t mind because I always seemed to work weird schedules. Long retired the switch screws with my internal clock and just makes me crabby.

Andy

Get rid of it. There is not a single plausible reason why we should keep it.

Comm Center Rat

I’ll let Boy George & Culture Club respond to this rather timely issue:

“Ooh in time it could have been so much more
The time is precious I know
In time it could have been so much more
The time has nothing to show because
Time won’t give me time and
Time makes lovers feel like they’ve got something real
But you and me we know they’ve got nothing but time
And time won’t give me time, won’t give me time (time, time, time)”

Time (Clock of the Heart), 1983

David

Old Indian chief:
Only white man stupid enough to think you tear a strip off one end of blanket and sew it on other end of blanket, that you get bigger blanket.

Dump it. Expensive waste.

OWB

Don’t really care what system we use to keep time but would sure like for somebody to pick one and we live with that system henceforth.

There is no daylight saved by DST. Same number of hours in the day no matter what you call each of those hours. Just as farmers farm from sun up to sundown without regard for what the clock says, every other entity which relies upon daylight to accomplish something or another will do so no matter the official time.

The only thing that changing the clocks twice each year accomplishes is to throw the country into near chaos as we all adjust to the change. Who decided that nationwide confusion is good for us? And why do we go along with whoever it was?

Nonsense.

RCAF-CHAIRBORNE

Daylight Savings Time usually resulted in a few minor AWOL charges amongst the Privates

OlafTheTanker

No.

Next Slide.

A W Andrews

Dump it. Businesses can have “summer hours.” This country observes DST 38 weeks out of the year. That’s way too long, by 38 weeks.

5th/77th FA

Say bye Felicia. Aggravating as hell for most of us in line construction. Unless it was an emergency, ie storm/accident/outage/damage, we had to wait for daylight to get more done. Even the best of artificial lights created shadows that made it more dangerous, especially when then lines close by were “hot.” And like many of you, throws my internal clock all to hell.

Sparks

The meager benefits it supposedly brings do not outway the inconvenience and sheer aggravation it seems to cause me. I say, do away with it.

Sparks

outweigh…pardon me.

11B-Mailclerk

It takes a Government to fark up clocks, twice a year.

Dump it. Go back to standard time. Folks set their schedules based on their lives. Who the fark needs to be “adjusted” twice a year based on someone else’s notion of when we should be out of bed or out of the house?

“Stupid” is insufficient to describe this utter farce of irrational authoritarian meddling.

AnotherPat

“8 Things You May Not Know About Daylight Saving Time: https://www.history.com/news/8-things-you-may-not-know-about-daylight-saving-time: (1) “It’s “daylight saving time,” not “daylight savings time. Many people render the term’s second word in its plural form. However, since the word “saving” acts as part of an adjective rather than a verb, the singular is grammatically correct.” (2) “Though in favor of maximizing daylight waking hours, Benjamin Franklin did not originate the idea of moving clocks forward. By the time he was a 78-year-old American envoy in Paris in 1784, the man who espoused the virtues of “early to bed and early to rise” was not practicing what he preached. After being unpleasantly stirred from sleep at 6 a.m. by the summer sun, the founding father penned a satirical essay in which he calculated that Parisians, simply by waking up at dawn, could save the modern-day equivalent of $200 million through “the economy of using sunshine instead of candles.” As a result of this essay, Franklin is often erroneously given the honor of “inventing” daylight saving time, but he only proposed a change in sleep schedules—not the time itself.” (3) “Englishman William Willett led the first campaign to implement daylight saving time. While on an early-morning horseback ride around the desolate outskirts of London in 1905, Willett had an epiphany that the United Kingdom should move its clocks forward by 80 minutes between April and October so that more people could enjoy the plentiful sunlight. The Englishman published the 1907 brochure “The Waste of Daylight” and spent much of his personal fortune evangelizing with missionary zeal for the adoption of “summer time.” Year after year, however, the British Parliament stymied the measure, and Willett died in 1915 at age 58 without ever seeing his idea come to fruition.” (4) “Germany was the first country to enact daylight saving time. It took World War I for Willett’s dream to come true, but on April 30, 1916, Germany embraced daylight saving time to conserve electricity. (He may have been horrified to learn that Britain’s wartime enemy followed his recommendations before his homeland.) Weeks later, the United Kingdom followed… Read more »

Tallywhagger

The best “lost” hour of sleep I get, all year long.

OTOH, set it and forget it. Use the same system all year and let the planets sort it out.

The only best thing I like about living in New England is the early sunrise in June. I have few good reasons to be up 04:30 other wanting to be. Early sunrise is the best good reason.

26Limabeans

At least the TAH server clock will be correct again so I can compete in WOT without doing the math.
The clocks in my house are UTC.
Everyone on the planet should be UTC.
No math needed.

Mason

Being in the frozen north, I’d rather stay on daylight time all year. Sun setting at 1630 in the winter is rough.

Garold

Scrap it. It was started for farmers. Now they are mechanized. I hear some say we get an extra hour of daylight and I shake my head. There’s but the same 24 hours each day.

OWB

Nope. It was never for farmers. Urban legend – the farmers were always against it.

Garold

Could be; my Aunt who raised me was full of such old rumors. Either way, we don’t need it though it does make for a good excuse for going into work for some I suppose.

OldCorpsTanker72

Get rid of it. It’s inconvenient, annoying, and serves no purpose.

26Limabeans

It’s like cutting off one end of a rug, sewing it back on the other end and thinking you have more rug.

RGR 4-78

Pick one time and stay with it, I am really tired of this switching crap twice a year.

Twist

Right now it benefits me so I say keep it. I get off night shift an hour early on Sunday because of it. Ask me again when it doesn’t benefit me and I will probably have a different answer.

Reddevil

I plan to run for president on this platform alone:

We keep daylight savings time, but we spring forward on a Friday afternoon at 1600, and spring back on a Monday at 0600.

You’re welcome, America.

RetiredDevilDoc8404

Get rid of it. Makes me crabby, messes with the dogs schedule. No earthly reason for it.

CDR_D

I hate changing the clocks twice a year. I also hate DST, because I am an early riser. Standard Time is the natural time for your longitude, and that should be the one that goes 365 a year. But libtard politicians, believing they outrank nature, will force everyone to do the opposite.

Kim J. Mettes

I have a 64 mile commute each way to work; therefore, I have an 03:15hr get-up every day whether DST (Daylight Saving Time) or DST (Daylight Standard Time)
The difference is that with Daylight Saving Time I have the extra hour of daylight in the afternoon – I feed horses, dogs and cats in the afternoon and do not relish feeding in the dark (and Cold) even just north of Houston, TX in the winter.

26Limabeans

TEST TEST TEST
This is only a test to see if the server time is now correct.
Had this been an actual emergency you would have been directed to tune to a local broadcast station for further instructions.

26Limabeans

Yep.

Lurker Curt

I’m already crabby, don’t need to upset my sleep cycle any more- I say set the damn click and leave it alone.