She coulda been a SEAL
This middle-aged lawyer lady from Long Island is suing the Navy. She was *this* close to fulfilling her lifelong dream of becoming the first female Navy SEAL. If only the Navy hadn’t slow-walked her application past the line where she was now too old. Those nefarious Navy recruiters risked missing their quota and signing a real live GI Jane.
Why would someone so committed to a life of naval service wait until the 11th hour to join? Well…She had been trying to enlist for a while, but apparently wasn’t any good at it. Attempting in 2018, 2019, and 2020. The latter attempt was foiled by her own inability to not drive drunk (allegedly).
A wannabe-G.I. Jane’s dream of becoming the first female Navy S.E.A.L. ended because military recruiters delayed her application so long that she aged out, she claimed in a lawsuit.
The US Navy officials failed to advance Amanda S. Reynolds’ application, then told her in the fall that she would no longer qualify for Naval Officer Training Command in Newport, RI, because she’d be over the age limit of 42 by the time she graduated, according to court papers.
“The opportunity . . . was kind of taken away from me. I would like that to be reinstated,” Reynolds, 41, told The Post. “I would just like the outcome to be determined by the merits instead of by some sort of technicality.
“I could have gone to officer candidate school in February, [but] they delayed my application without reason or cause and then they told me I was too old,” she said.
The Long Island lawyer first sought to join the Navy in 2018.
“I was working in litigation for 12 years, and I kind of got burnt out working 24/7,” the Woodbury resident said, calling the SEALs “such a more noble cause.”
An avid long-distance runner and swimmer who is SCUBA certified, Reynolds said the special forces “kind of jibed with my physical pursuits.”
In a personal statement submitted as part of her efforts to enlist, Reynolds wrote of her “Viking-like pursuit” to be a SEAL.
“As an American, I was born with what I can only describe as an inexpressible, indefatigable nature to dream,” she wrote. “And so, dream I do — never forgetting it is only under the auspices of this great nation’s military who protects my inalienable right to do so that I may.”
Service runs in the family, Reynolds said. Her grandfather served in the Norwegian Ski Patrol; her uncle was an American World War II pilot shot down in the Pacific, and her older brother is an FBI agent.
“I hope to serve as this country’s first female Navy SEAL Officer, so that there may be a second, and a third, and an infinitesimal many more female candidates who might impress upon you these shared values in the very same way,” she wrote.
But her dream stalled almost from the get-go.
Reynolds, who is representing herself in her Brooklyn Federal Court age-discrimination case against the US Navy, claimed she was “sworn into” the Navy in Brooklyn in 2018 but “was never assigned anywhere or deployed.”
Reynolds filled out “enlistment paperwork” in 2019, according to the Navy, which had “no record of service” for her.
She then moved to Utah where she worked as a lawyer and revisited her enlistment in 2020. But she was was arrested in July 2020 for allegedly driving under the influence, a misdemeanor which was dismissed in 2023, court records show.
She returned to Long Island and again chased her dreams of joining the SEALs, but found recruiters were quick to urge her to use her legal skills in the military’s Judge Advocate General.
She claims recruiters told her that “age waivers were always obtainable.”
“I was really gearing up to participate in the pipeline process, really taking all the right steps to proceed with the application,” she said. But the app “was not submitted” by recruiters and “unjustifiably delayed,” she claimed.
The Navy declined comment on the litigation.
The Defense Department opened the military’s elite units, such as the SEALs and the Army’s Green Berets, to women in 2016 but no woman has ever finished the process to become a SEAL.
“It was never really about me being a female SEAL, it was just about me being a SEAL who happened to be a woman,” she said.
It’s really the Navy’s loss here that such a spectacular officer and special operations candidate that would have busted down barriers and brought much needed real life experience on the dangers of consuming intoxicating substances and operating motor vehicles to the troops.
Category: Dumbass Bullshit, Navy, SEALs, YGBSM!!
She shoulda spent more time in the kitchen…or at least known how to make a sammich. After all…you gotta be a cook to be a Navy SEAL…right? Who ever heard of a lawer becoming a SEAL?
Or she could go to work at All-Points Logistics.
Phil Monkress is probably salivating over this potential hire.
Well, she already checked the box for DUI, so she has that going for her, which is nice.
But does she have bankruptcies like whatshisface, I mean Psul?
There’s a joke in there that won’t be repeated as I don’t want to get an email from the admins that begins with.. Dear Odie, we have received complaints…
No ballz!
Buuuut maaaaaybe?
Give her nine recycles and send her to Ranger School.
Sure did take her a long time to act on her “Viking-like pursuit” to be a SEAL. Sounds like a Grade-B bullshit artist to me. She’s a lawer, so it’s a requirement.
Everyone wants to be a SEAL until it’s time to do SEAL things…
Nope. I’ll just eat at the Trident Grille once in a while. It’s the same thing, right?
Then they want to go Signal.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I could have played in the NFL, if I wanted to……..buuuut, I wasn’t good enough. Where do these people come from? The arrogance is through the roof, but the stupidity level is even higher.
I could have been a medical doctor had it not been for a few obstacles: 1) organic chemistry 2) physics 3) biology, etc.
Same. I’m allergic to blood and guts, specially if they aren’t in the live owner.
I just don’t like the idea of inserting needles in to human bodies. I’m ok with the cutting into them and patching them up and surprisingly even stitching them up. I guess I should not have given up my dream, and maybe need to go back and sue the government for processing my application for being a Ranger and not first thinking I could have been a doctor! Or maybe a lawyer, or a physicist (ohh, wait that was me deciding not to study Nuclear Physics on scholarship, and instead do the Engineering with all the hot babes…)!
NFL? No, that’s too dangerous. You might be hurt.
Right now, at my age and physical condition, my 3 year old granddaughter hurts me when she jumps on my back. God help me when my twin grandsons are a little older and gang up on me to wrestle, they will hurt me for sure!
I could have been a guitar Rock god…..but I’m musically retarded and couldn’t even play the triangle
If I would identify as a frog and I had wings, I wouldn’t bump my ass when I hopped and I could probably run for the head of the DNC. Or vice president or something.
“I was working in litigation for 12 years, and I kind of got burnt out working 24/7,”
Because SEALs don’t work nights or weekends.
Better headline-“How to get 15 minutes of fame, entitled delusional style”.
Sit down and shut up you disgrace to the gender. But par for the course for too many female lawyers
This reminds me of the first OIC I worked for as an officer in the USN. I was at his house for a wardroom get together and he told me that he had been a teacher before joining the Navy.
When I asked why he left that profession to become a naval officer, he said, “I got tired of telling people what to do”.
I almost burst out laughing, but thank the Lord I caught myself cause he was deadly serious. Nice guy but he proved that statement correct in the time I worked for him.
Well, I was working in litigation for over twenty years, and the absolute last thing I would ever consider attempting was BUD/S. Ranger School when I was 22 was bad enough for a lifetime.
I must say I hated dealing with female lawers. Most were quite unpleasant to experience. Fortunately, in litigation, they were few and far between as opponents back in the 80’s and 90’s.
From what I read, enlisted SEAL recruits have to be 18-28 with waivers available on case-by-case basis for up 35. Why would the officer limit be 41? In small units like this, officers & enlisted MUST be able to do the same highly demanding and physical skills. You can’t have the El Tee lagging behind the rest of platoon. Anybody could this argument for anything they’re not qualified/capable of doing by applying for it right before they age out. Representing herself tells you the NO reputable lawyer would touch that case with a 10′ pole. What’s old saying: Anyone the represents themselves in court has a fool for a client.
The maximum age for OCS is 36, uniform across all branches. The maximum age for direct commission is normally 40 (JAG, doctors, etc) and 42 for chaplains; although with a waiver some services will go as high as 50 if they really need a special skill or faith, such as an anesthesiologist or Catholic Priest or the son of the VP. This mostly has to do with shortages and the level of education required.
So far as a an age waiver for Special Operations commission I have never heard of such a thing for someone with or without a driveshaft.
If I had to guess a recruiter was stringing her along, knowing full well she would never be eligible to go SEAL and then hoping she would flip to JAG when she figured out SEAL wasn’t ever going to happen.
The Navy is looking into the BUDS training where a Sailor died duiring one of those long training evolutions which I forgot what they were called. I heard that maybe there methods were a little physicaly harsh. We had a Seal Rep come aboard when they were in the process of starting up the Seals in early 1964 looking for volunteers. The late “John” Arnold Daily was a Long Beach LI NY Detective and former Seal and went to Viet-Nam. He had a ring loaded with VC ears on it. Went into the Coast guard and was in the first Gulf war working in law enforcement in one of the cities which he told me once but I can’t remember. Over 6 ft tall and was a Lifeguard.
True!
It takes someone with good mental attitude, stamina, and upper body strength to be a seal. She would have washed out the first week. And she had opportunity to pursue being a seal, she didn’t have the mental attitude to pursue it. And it appears the recruiters were spot on in denying this turd the opportunity to waste a slot on a wannabe. With no chance of being a seal to start with. Now She’s just looking to cash in on her perceived failures that she created. Probably never finishes anything she starts, including this law suit.
She finished that pitcher of Margaritas.
Well, she is representing herself, and what’s that old saying about lawyers representing themselves?
They have fools for clients.
She is likely representing herself because any attorney with a brain can see how stupid this lawsuit is. Not much chance of succeeding with the age requirement being passed many years ago. And her failure to complete enlistment or application to the service years ago. That’s likely why they have no record of miss wannabe. Recruiters saw what a waste of time she was in applying after age requirements had passed. And any statements of waivers needs to be in writing. Her only hope in succeeding is to wear a wet T-shirt, maybe playboy will pickup the story line as a wet seal babe photo shoot.
Playboy’s standards have dropped that much?
I don’t think she would get an age waiver from Playboy, even though she obviously excels in the “dumb blonde(?)” category.
Criminal misconduct with alcohol has foiled the careers of thousands of Meal Team operators. Luckily they can always have a career as a digital operator and fill in all the blanks as to what would have happened.
The last time that Big Navy offered an age waiver for an Officer appointment, the guy popped for Coke on Day 1.
Let’s look at it realistically. US Navy SEAL training has one of the highest attrition rates in the US Military training. So she wants to take a shot at the age of 42 with zero military experience while also being the oldest student and most likely only female student in the training cycle? You don’t need Hack Stone’s Magic 8-Ball to see how this will turn out. But just to assuage anyone’s concern, let us ask. “Oh, wise and all knowing Magic 8-Ball, would Amanda S. Reynolds graduate US Navy SEAL training?” Magic 8-Ball says…
I say send her ass. What is the worst that could happen? She will be ringing that bell like a five alarm fire day 2. She can then wallow in tears peeling onions for five year in the mess.
And if by some miracle she makes it then that is a win too.
She’s no Casey Ryback.
Does he have a Russian name now????
There is some channel on YouTube that seems to exist only to dissect and make of Steven Seagal movies, mostly his later “work” that was released straight to video. They do an outstanding job of savaging his “performances.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gkXbDEgYSNo&pp=ygUVU3RldmVuIHNlYWdhbCByZXZpZXdz
Check out their other posts. In accordance with This Ain’t Hells Terms of Service, Hack Stone’s is issuing a Preemptive Level IV Spew Alert.
Yep. Space Ice crushes Segal every time.
Fat ass Steven Seagal versus Ranger Stephen “Cio” Burrell.
What a fight!
Stephen CIO Burrell will kill you with an entrenching tool; Steven Seagal will kill you with a drinking glass, as demonstrated in the video above. Hack Stone has seen a handful of their takedowns of Seagal movies, and every time you think that he can’t sink any lower, Seagal takes it as a challenge. His films have to be part of some drug money laundering scheme, because no legitimate film producer would put this dreck on the market.
Navy Boot camp started a training program for enlisties that wanted to be Seals so that they would be prepaired for Buds. A few years ago, their was a young Seal from Long Island NY whose older brother was a Seal and set up a training area in the back yard to get his brother a head start including a pool in the yard for the pool buds training.
She’d have a lawsuit for discrimination.
I wonder what the Magic 8 Ball would have said if I had one when the Seal recruiter came aboard our ship back in 1964 looking for volunteers.
Even among young Sailors in great shape, I hear that BUDS has maybe a 25-30% Graduation rate!
I had a SGT worked for me in 2010, prior service Navy, told me he attempted BUDS. I asked him what happened, he said “I quit after the third time those fuckin’ sonsabitches tried to drown me!”
I’m with What’shisname!
Less than that, according to a 2023 news release.
https://www.sandboxx.us/news/special-ops/new-navy-report-reveals-rare-seal-training-attrition-data/
I’d like to see her run five miles with a 40 lb. rucksack across rough terrain. She would be ringing the bell after about one mile.
She’d make it THAT far?
Her lawsuit sets a dangerous precedent. Imagine all those guys out there who were “going to join the Navy and become a SEAL” and never even went to MEPS. This means they can all blame the Navy for their failure to become a SEAL.
For real though, I doubt she would have made it past the first week of BUDS, and that’s ASSuming she made it through OCS and commissioned and they Navy didn’t send her off to some other pipeline. I’m sure there is always a slot available at Surface Warfare.
That is the new pipeline to All-Points Logistics.
The opportunity wasn’t taken from here, she squandered it. If she wanted to serve, she had decades to join, but she didn’t. Even if SEAL was here goal, she should have stepped up 8 years ago. I get interview candidates like this all the time. They “always wanted to be an ER nurse…” but spent the last 20 years doing something else.
Next!
I sat on a board for a guy who wanted to get a commission. I asked him if he was prepared to go to sea.
“I’d have to ask my wife”.
Next!
Ah, here’s an oldie but goodie:
When Hack Stone was on Recruiting Duty, one kid bailed on enlisting because his parents promised him a Pontiac Fiero if he did sign.
Fiero?! Wow! That dates Hack Stone. I don’t know if he got the better end of that deal, however. My sister had one in the mid-80s and it was a maintenance hog. Oh, and you had to pull the full engine to do any work on it.
The “I almost served guy” is always a classic, but I favor the “Maybe I did or maybe I didn’t serve guy”. You see he’s checking to see if anybody within ear-shot served. If not, he’ll bust his out sooper-dooper secret squirrel stories.
Earlier today Hack Stone was speaking to a fellow Marine who went to Radio Repairman School with him way back 40 plus years ago. We had a conversation about one particular classmate who went UA between Basic Electronics Course and Radio Fundamentals Course, was busted down, knocked up his High School sweetheart, who he brought out to 29 Stumps to marry, where they promptly left a long trail of bounced all over Morongo Valley. After graduation, he was assigned to Electronics Maintenance Company, where he continued to stiff retail establishments on and off base. Sun performer on PFTs, always a headache for the command, of course his wife left him, etc. You know the drill. So eventually the Marine Corps assigned him to the AEP (Accelerated Enlistment Program) where it was decided that it would be in best interest of all parties if he and the Marine Corps parted ways. So, his four year enlistment ended around the two year mark. You would never know that he was kicked out, since he is always posting on Fakebook about meeting other Marines who compliment him on his USMC t-shirts, hats and license plates. Too bad he didn’t have the enthusiasm during his enlistment.
Or the rite stuff.
My friends step-daughter had a tumultuous time in the Navy. She followed a guy from high school into the service, married him in A-School, separated from him, and then got kicked out when she began cutting herself. She’s been out 3 years but her ‘About page’ on FB lists former Navy as the first thing.
Disgusting tuuuuurd!
She might be ok for wet t-shirt workouts.
Wet T Shirt, If she could keep her mouth shut.
If she succeeds, standby for Hillary to dust off that old story about how she almost joined the Marine Corps and send in that frivolous lawsuit. If she is bold, she’ll parlay that almost a Marine thing into a combat action ribbon for dodging sniper fire in Bosnia. Her back pay will be insane. You go, girl.
You did know she was named after a famous mountaineer, right? And I ain’t talking about Jed Clampett.
“You’re too old, too short and you can’t see, go down the block, maybe the dogs (US Army) will take you!!” – Quote from a USMC Recruiter that Das Hildebeast alleges was made.
Love that laser-like focus… from being “sworn in” (maybe she meant “sworn at”?) in 2018 she instantly recognized she wasn’t at BUDs yet only two years later! God, what reflexes!
Total bullshit artist. Sworn in but never assigned anywhere? Sure. Whatever you say.
Happens all the time. They swear you in before you even put your bags in the luggage room at MEPS.
Are you saying that you can get sworn in, and then nothing else happens? Doesn’t make sense.
Enlist at MEPS on the Delayed Entry Program, then completely go off grid before the shipping date. Sort of like Elaine Ricci disappearing from the board room on Wilson Lane in Bethesda.
Sorry ’bout that, should’ve put the /s/ tag at the end.
No foul. Hack Stone should have updated his Sarcasm Recognition Software. It’s pretty difficult keeping a Commodore 64 humming, requires as much maintenance as a 1980’s vintage Jaguar.
Commodore 64?? Must be nice to be rich!!
Anyone have a cassette head cleaner?
Trash-80 Model III was better.

I was THIS close to being awarded the coveted Green Beret, if only I had actually walked up to the table the SF recruiters had set up in the foyer of my local PX three and a half decades ago.
Sounds like another Youth who went through MEPS alongside A Proud Infidel®™ the day he shipped, he was supposed to have shipped for USCG Basic, but during his DEP time he ended up getting a DUI and Minor in Possession charges which got him a release from contract and a Grey-mutt bus ticket home, I wonder if he could now sue the USCG because he could have been a Mark 1, Mod 0 Rescue Swimmer but was denied? I dunno, sounds like a cheap publicity stunt to me, like that 500-pound beached whale of a she-Rapper who sued Lyft because one of their Drivers didn’t want to destroy his seats, tires and suspension by hauling her (She lost that suit a la Bernath)!
The Lyft Driver should have provided her the number for the Dispatch Center at Swift Trucking.
Tom’s Towing is good for that.
Nut.
The slow-walkers saved everyone much time, money, and effort.
She coulda made SEAL’s Samwhiches…
Wasn’t this the plot of a JAG episode?