Lt Col’s Memorial Day speech cut off in mid-sentence. Intentionally.

| June 4, 2021

US Army Lt. Col. Barnard Kemter (ret)

This was sent in by a couple people over the last few days and I’m just now getting to it. Apologies. It’s the mid-90’s here and the pool is open. Hard to want to sit behind the computer.

The Akron Beacon Journal first reported it, but it’s also been picked up by the Washington Post. It seems Colonel Kemter’s speech on the history of Memorial Day, given on Memorial Day last week, was cut off. When the mic went dead, he assumed (like most people would) that it was a malfunction. Nope. They did it on purpose. Right as he was getting to the origins of Memorial Day being started by freed slaves after the Civil War.

From the Akron Beacon Journal;

What at first blush appeared to be a short audio malfunction at Monday’s Memorial Day ceremony in Markillie Cemetery turned out to be anything but.

A ceremony organizer turned off the microphone when the event’s keynote speaker, retired Army Lt. Col. Barnard Kemter, began sharing a story about freed Black slaves honoring deceased soldiers shortly after the end of the Civil War.

The microphone was turned down for about two minutes in the middle of Kemter’s 11-minute speech during the event hosted by the Hudson American Legion Lee-Bishop Post 464.

Cindy Suchan, who chairs the Memorial Day parade committee and is president of the Hudson American Legion Auxiliary, said it was either her or Jim Garrison, adjutant of American Legion Lee-Bishop Post 464, who turned down the audio. When pressed, she would not say who specifically did it.

Suchan said organizers wanted this part excluded because it “was not relevant to our program for the day,” and added the “theme of the day was honoring Hudson veterans.”

Kemter said he wanted to use his speech to share the history of the origin of Memorial Day. Afterward, he noted, he received “numerous compliments” from attendees who told him “it was nice to hear the history.”

“It was well-received,” Kemter said, adding many people told him, “I never knew that.”

He expressed disappointment with the event organizers’ actions.

“I find it interesting that [the American Legion] … would take it upon themselves to censor my speech and deny me my First Amendment right to [freedom of] speech,” Kemter said. “… This is not the same country I fought for.”

Kemter, a 1962 Hudson High School graduate, said he was trained as a combat medic, was in the U.S. Army from 1965 to 1995, and served in the Persian Gulf War.

In the days leading up to the ceremony, Suchan said she reviewed Kemter’s speech and asked him to remove certain portions.

“We asked him to modify his speech, and he chose not to do that,” said Suchan.

Suchan declined to say which part she wanted excluded, but confirmed the two minutes when Kemter’s microphone was turned off were part of what she asked him to exclude. During those two minutes, Kemter is heard discussing how former slaves and freed Black men shortly after the Civil War exhumed the remains of more than 200 Union soldiers who died in battle in Charleston and gave them “a proper burial.”

About three days before the ceremony, Kemter said, he was emailed by an event organizer (whom he declined to name) asking him to remove a part of his speech dealing with Black Americans’ role in an early Memorial Day-type of ceremony. Kemter declined to share why the organizer asked him to remove this part, but said he asked the organizer to specify what portions they wanted to have excluded.

When he received an email back from the organizer Sunday evening, the message stated that the parts to be removed were highlighted. Kemter said he did not see any text highlighted — and with the ceremony less than 24 hours away, he did not reply again.

“I didn’t have time to sit down and rewrite another speech,” Kemter said.

Kemter said he showed the text of the speech to a Hudson public official, who advised him to leave the speech intact.

At a certain point in Kemter’s speech, Suchan said she asked A.J. Stokes, the event’s audio engineer, to turn off Kemter’s microphone. She said Stokes refused to do it himself, but pointed to the knob that controlled the microphone.

Stokes confirmed his refusal and that he did point to the knob. He said it was Garrison who turned down the audio and then turned it back up a short time later.

When reached by phone Wednesday, Garrison declined to say whether he turned down the microphone and said he had “nothing to add” regarding the situation.

Stokes said Suchan and Garrison were both “very adamant” about turning off Kemter’s microphone.

“That was very improper,” Stokes said. “I would’ve never done something like that.”

There’s more at the source(s). Here’s the text of the colonel’s speech.

To his credit, Kemter said, “I decided, ‘I don’t need a microphone.’ I just proceeded in my Army command voice.”

Category: "Teh Stoopid", "The Floggings Will Continue Until Morale Improves", Historical, Liberals suck

27 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anonymous

Were these idiots or people who want “evil racist veterans” blamed?

Ret_25X

OK, time to cancel them. Who wants to bet that the VFW folks involved either are not veterans at all, or not veterans of foreign wars?

I’ll leave the Larsie like actions of censoring truth to others to take apart.

Ret_25X

so it is an AL post and this happened on the 4th:

https://www.beaconjournal.com/story/news/2021/06/04/hudson-american-legion-posts-charter-suspended-leader-resigns/7543211002/

It seems the Ohio Dept Commander took immediate action.

Sapper3307

SPASH!

26Limabeans

I like swift action.

MarineDad61

Ret_25X,
Although VFW has plenty of issues, member eligibility among them,
the American Legion has their own similar but different issues.
Glad to see the AL Ohio Dept. Commander get involved.

Ret_25X

I wonder if they thought any talk about the origins of Memorial Day would get them dragged by the Larsie Boi Brigade…

Or if they are run of the mill lefties (aka racists)

11B-Mailclerk

Did not fit the Marxist narrative.

gitarcarver

“I find it interesting that [the American Legion] … would take it upon themselves to censor my speech and deny me my First Amendment right to [freedom of] speech,” Kemter said. “… This is not the same country I fought for.”

I find it interesting that the man who claims he fought for the First Amendment doesn’t know what the First Amendment means.

akpual

Seems he doesn’t.

Just An Old Dog

Those Morons need to be fired from their positions.
While the actions of those freed slaves may not have had the national recognition at the time or even be the catalyst for the Holiday it was truly one of the first efforts to recognize

OWB

What a concept- including the history of Memorial Day in a speech on Memorial Day. Strange. Very, very strange that anyone would object to it or fail to see the significance of his words.

‘splain to us just how sharing stories about how and who originally honored those who died in battle detracts from the theme of Memorial Day. ’cause I just don’t see it.

What the leaders did do was show themselves to be idiotic control freaks. I have personally addressed a few groups on holidays, even been a keynote speaker a time or two and have never had to submit my words for preapproval. Fools. Glad they got what they worked so hard to earn.

gitarcarver

With all due respect, we may not know enough about this.

The post said they asked for a speech concentrating on those who gave their lives and were from the Hudson Valley.

If that is true, and Kemter went off the script and was reminded not to do it, then Kemter basically said “you aren’t the boss of me.”

I think there are legitimate concerns raised into the behavior of everyone.

The question for the post is whether the post wanted Kemter not to discuss Charleston because of race issues or because it was off the topic they requested.

The question for Kemter is whether he took the engagement, knowing the parameters, and then said “I don’t have to stay within those parameters and you can’t hold me to the agreement.”

I don’t see anyone looking good in this case.

Penguinman000

His speech was provided ahead of time. They asked him to remove the portion in question. He said no. Instead of changing speakers they pressed ahead and the turned down the volume.

More importantly, IMHO, with the current divisions we have in this country a speech highlighting sacrifice of white men on behalf of African Americans being honored spontaneously by African Americans is a perfect example of the unity Memorial Day should bring. We’re all Americans and men/women better than us paid the ultimate sacrifice so we can have what we do.

The AL suspending the post until its disestablished and removing the 2 culprits from the rolls is exactly the correct response.

To paraphrase a certain general “if I wipe the name I may remove the stain. “

gitarcarver

They asked him to remove the portion in question. He said no.

No, he said nothing. He didn’t respond which in and of itself shows that this is a problem where no one was correct.

More importantly, IMHO, with the current divisions we have in this country a speech highlighting sacrifice of white men on behalf of African Americans being honored spontaneously by African Americans is a perfect example of the unity Memorial Day should bring.

I would agree if that was the topic of the speech he was asked to give. He wasn’t asked to give that speech. He was asked to give a speech on a specific topic and not only said “no,” he acted just as badly as the post commanders.

OWB

No, we likely know very little compared to the complete story on this. Or any other story we opine about. 😉

5JC

I know the heat is getting to him but was it Veteran’s Day or Mememorial Day?

AW1Ed

You knew the job was dangerous when you took it.
*grin*

MCPO USN

An 11 minute speech? He couldn’t have got off topic very much.

Regardless, turning the mic off is third-grade recess bullshit. Just don’t invite him back next year if you don’t like it. We all have a story that goes “remember when that guy gave that speech and said all that crazy shit. What was that all about?”

MOH recipient Robert L. Howard gave a speech to us in Kuwait winter of 2006. He started ranting about how the military was screwing up the current conflict. They tried to shut him up and then apologized for his comments. Turns out he was right.

11B-Mailclerk

“Duty. Honor. Country.”

Or is it

“Admit no wrong”

KoB

Pay Honors to ALL Honorable Veterans on Veterans Day.

Pay Honors to ALL of the Honorable War Dead on Memorial Day.

ALL of Them! That’s the way we roll.

USAF E-5

Just finished reading his speech. Very nicely done. Got a little dusty.

Old tanker

I have looked up the origin of Memorial day. The speech was incorrect. While freed slaves did honor over 200 union dead in 1865, the real Memorial day was initiated in 1868 by a proclamation of Maj. Gen. Logan who called it Decoration day. Later it was designated as the last Monday in May as a Federal holiday in 1968 by Congress.

https://www.history.com/topics/holidays/memorial-day-history

Jus Bill

Just goes to show that you can’t keep a good man down.

Only Army Mom

I’m confused by comments here suggesting the Lt. Col. may have been in the wrong because he did not redact part of his speech. This baffles me because while I generally support withholding judgement sans all the pertinents, too often of late it simply gives cover to the inexcusable.

The request was issued by an event organizer. Available evidence points to that being Suchon, an Auxiliary member (read-never served), who is listed as the Chair of the Committee organizing the event. The temerity and audacity are astounding.

I’ve never heard of a Memorial Day speaker being asked to provide a copy of their speech before-hand so it can be edited or approved. Occasionally, organizers request a written copy so they can prepare quotes or copies for journalists or for run of show organization. But to edit for approval purposes? The Lt. Col. chose the valorous part of discretion by not responding as the other option would be to cancel his speech. The fact that he is a hometown boy probably weighed heavily on his decision.

The idea that a retired Lt. Col., a local boy who made good would be edited by some pissant Karen – or her male counterpart, the adjutant of a pissant AL post is laughable. This local boy talking about the history of Memorial Day, including an anecdotal story of the significance of the day to him, is wholly appropriate.

If the event organizers had an agenda which they were so desperate to air, it is on them to find a speaker who agrees with and will parrot their agenda. The idea they will censor another who obviously doesn’t agree with their agenda is an epic affront- to the speaker, the audience, and not least of all, those who the event ostensibly honors.

The only reason my blood pressure did not explode when I first heard about this is because it was after the Ohio AL took action. Swift, appropriate action.