Waving a Hero
I’d like to introduce a new term into the political lexicon: waving a hero. For that is precisely what America’s commander-in-chief, Barack Obama, did last week at the conclusion of his State of the Union speech. As an old infantry sergeant, I was watching that young Ranger NCO from the time he entered the chamber, taking note of the fact that he was seated next to the first lady. I told my wife right then, “He’s there as a prop, they’re going to use him.”
Unfortunately for me, and the young sergeant first class, Cory Remberg, we all had to sit there through the entire boring speech for both of us to be validated. He received his sorely earned tribute with an extended standing ovation by all present in the chamber. However, being the cynic that life has made me, I knew that the duration of the ovation was largely based on the fact that both parties feared being the first to sit down. I’m just an undergraduate cynic; those duly elected members in that chamber have advanced degrees in that finely honed sense of distrust, disbelief, and “do whatever it takes.”
American Thinker had a recent post by a young Marine officer who tried to defray the charges of cynicism being leveled at the Obama administration for its callous exploitation of a grievously wounded combat veteran. This Marine wisely noted that Pericles had eons ago explained why young warriors must sometimes be sacrificed for the good of a virtuous state. But, and that is a huge but, the essence of Pericles’s observation is that the nation being defended must be one of virtue and truth, and therefore worthy of defense and the resulting sacrifice of its brave warriors.
As someone who fought in ground combat in Vietnam, I agree with that. At no time in my service there did I feel like I was fighting to protect hearth and home back in America from invasion by Asian hordes. I accepted that I was a small cog in the vast machine that my country, my supposedly virtuous country, had employed to counter the machinations and threats of those other superpowers, China and Russia, on the chessboard of their Southeast Asian strategy.
I would wager that if you surveyed surviving veterans of all the wars this country has fought since WWII, you would find that the two most prevalent emotions are first pride in service and then, most disturbingly, a disillusionment that they will carry to their graves that they were somehow used — simple pawns moved about to protect the political queens and kings. Yet we look at the larger battlefield and realize that no matter if our service and sacrifice were misused in certain campaigns, what we fought and died for was the particular mission assigned us by this greatest nation the world has ever seen. That is the Pericles justification for sacrificing our young warriors. We believed in America — and I’m certain that that is still the driving force within those who now serve.
No pity wanted here, though; we’re not looking for that. We are that proud few who stood when called and served — and as such, we do not look favorably upon a so-called commander-in-chief who uses one of our own’s badly battle-battered body as a political prop to shore up his piss-poor performance as a leader of America’s fighting forces. I would hope that future commanders-in-chief would have the decency to refrain from making a prop of such a grievously injured warrior.
This nation has done an acceptable job of honoring and recompensing those who fought on its behalf: G.I. Bill benefits enabled millions of us to get college degrees and buy homes. I availed myself of both. The health benefits promised us are an entire book unto themselves, a tome filled with grievance. The one thing our country seems to have done well is to establish beautiful national cemeteries where our remains can rest among our fellow veterans.
But please, no more waving of heroes for political drama.
Crossposted at American Thinker
Category: Barack Obama/Joe Biden
Very well done, Poetrooper. When I saw SFC Remberg seated beside FLOTUS I had that feeling too. Dog and pony show is what a first sergeant told me one time, its all just a big fricken dog and pony show.
I took another message from that moment.
A crowd in a room has a feeling and a rhythm all its own. They have very few ways to respond, but they do use those ways. That’s why some people have, from time to time, tried to use applause meters. Crowds in Washington have a well-developed language of applause.
To me, it was very clear that the applause for that young man was of a distinct character — longer and more enthusiastic — than for anything the President said. That was purposeful. That is one reason why the news media made mention of it. They noticed, too.
Everybody in that room knew there was going to be an obligatory prop serviceman. The level and timing of the applause, making it distinct from the applause about what the President had to say, was the only way to direct a message to the man.
It was well done, and while I agree with you that there were doubtless a few people who were afraid to sit down too soon, I chalk that up to the tribute that “vice to virtue pays.” Forcing our Congressional hypocrites to stand a few seconds longer and applaud was a feature, not a bug.
Well at least he didn’t have a couple of Marines standing by the podium holding the teleprompters
A self-cenetered politician willing to cynically and shamelessly use the military for his own selfish gain? Say it ain’t so…
He is the same person who parades the poor parents of the children killed in new town out in front of a camera for a political agenda. Disgusting.
I would say that there’s another side, a reminder that we are still at war and that a very small minority of us are making the extreme sacrifices necessary. I would say that, except that only 11% of the American people watched the State of the Union. So did that message get across?
Thank you Poetrooper. I cannot add to what you wrote. Well said.
Well I guess the term “Waving a Hero” is apropos. It has a nice double meaning. The other being like Pro Sports teams, when they are done with you, you are gone. You get Waived.
Amen.
Sad but true
I hope that DAV or some other service organization takes SFC Remberg under their wing to make sure that the VA doesn’t screw him as they have others when he leaves the service of country. He deserves better as he has given so much.
If only Obama was the first.
Every single State of the Union has had some member of the Military present. Both Parties love to “wave the hero”, and the public just eats it up. If you think for one second that the Republican Party is not as guilty of putting up the military as a political prop you would be sorely mistaken… and I am a registered Republican.
It is all well and good if we agree with the political ideology of hte person “waving the hero” though. Or is it?
To me, I am not so pissed off that SFC Remberg was there that night. The recognition he has gotten, the recognition of the plight and suffering so many of our Brothers in Arms have gone through being shoved into the public light after being mainly ignored is not a bad thing!
The motivations behind his being present, sure that is debatable from the perspective of a President who has been a crappy Commander in Chief, and all the recent cuts made to military and veterans benefits. Just do not act like Democrats are the only ones to “wave a hero”. They just suck at it, and it seems so much more obvious to us because of the disdain so many of them hold the Military in.