American Legion takes on ACLU’s FOIA

| May 8, 2009

This is exactly why I joined the American Legion last week. David Rehbein, the national commander of the American Legion writes a fiery missive in the Wall Street Journal today in regards to the ACLU’s FOIA filing for photographs of alleged abuse of detainees at the hands of US forces in Iraq. Mr. Rehbein’s piece is titled “Photos that could cost lives“;

Releasing photographs of alleged or actual detainee abuse in the War on Terrorism is not worth the life of a single American. Of course, as some have noted, the incidents at Abu Ghraib have already endangered our troops. So did any orders and policies that may have led to those incidents. But what is to be accomplished by continuing to provide ammunition and provocation to the enemy?

ACLU’s filing is nothing more than a transparent attempt to turn the world against us. That world that riots at the sight of political cartoons and unfounded rumors about Korans flushed down the toilet. Al Qaeda claimed that their beheading of Nick Berg was in retaliation for the last photos that were released in regards to supposed torture. Two American soldiers held captive were also beheaded in retaliation. How many lives is ACLU willing to sacrifice for the next round of scandal?

Mr Rehbein continues;

I was deeply disturbed by the images of Abu Ghraib. The military, however, has investigated the abuses and punished those involved. Moreover, the photographs that are now about to be released are already being used for investigative purposes. Other than self-flagellation by certain Americans, riots and future terrorist acts, what else do people expect will come from the release of these photographs?

At least the American Legion is willing to stand up for troops and says what needs to be said. In fact, the American Legion has led the VSOs in standing up for the troops since the war against terror began, they’ve been especially vigilant over the last few months when we’ve need them most. Mr Rehbein explains why;

As commander of the nation’s largest veterans service organization, I have had the honor to present Blue Star Banners to military families, with the Blue Star signifying the deployment of a service member. It is always a moving experience. But it is the Gold Star Banner, the star that signifies the death of a service member in war, that I never hope to present. I fear that there will be many Gold Stars as a result of this misbegotten policy.

Next month, I proudly join the ranks of Blue Star families as my only son gets deployed to Afghanistan and it’s reassuring to know that the folks at the American Legion are checking his six.

Category: Antiwar crowd, Barack Obama/Joe Biden, Foreign Policy, Terror War, Usual Suspects

11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Old Tanker

Active member of Post 29 for the last 18 years, “for God and Country”

Old Tanker

BTW, good luck to your son, tell him thanks!!

Barbara Kerr

My son is currently deployed to Afghanistan. Would he have taken part in what happened at Abu Gharib? I don’t know. I’m not sure he knows either.

He is a career military officer, who enlisted as a private, went through several training schools, and on to train as an officer. At the time of his enlistment, he held a Master’s Degree. He has over 15 years of service to our country.

I raised my son to respect life. I tried to teach him that killing another man was wrong. I protested the Vietnam War. I have always, and still ardently support our soldiers and their families and our Veterans – both personally and professionally.

As individuals, we do not know what we will do, how we will react in any given situation.

The release of these photos at this late date serves no purpose other than to incense the enemy and serve as “cannon foder” for our enlisted personnel.

I strongly respect, support, and admire National Commander David Rehbein of The American Legion.

At one time in my life, I respected the ACLU. This is no longer true.

An Army Mom and proud Blue Star Mother, Blue Star Grandmother, and soon to be, Blue Star Grandmother-in-Law.

UpNorth

Good post Jonn, tell your son thanks for his service, you too Barbara. My son just arrived in Afghanistan last Wednesday, got the first e-mail on Friday, so he’s been there a little over a week. And I’m looking for an American Legion post nearby.

Anonymous

The American Legion is leading the way on many hot topics lately and they make me proud that I am a member. Where are the other VSO’s anyway?

Ray

Welcome aboard Jonn. Now all we need to do is get you on a motorcycle and have you join the Legion Riders and we’ll have a “welcome home” ride when your son returns. 🙂

Gods Speed to your son, and Up North’s and Barbara’s. May their deployments be safe and successful.

ponsdorf

Jonn said: I joined the American Legion last week.

While the broader issue is well past important, there’s a fun bit as well.

I met a guy who works for the Legion at the conference, and asked if he now worked for me. I can’t characterize the look I got… but priceless might work.

UpNorth

Thanks Ray, much appreciated. By the way, on the Fox news trailer tonight, it said something about SecDef Gates saying that because of the speed of the Obama “surge” in Afghanistan, soldiers and Marines were being deployed there “underequipped”. Anyone have anything on this? I haven’t heard anything from my son, but am curious if units or individuals are being deployed without everything they need.

TSO

UpNorth, they are at Camp Leatherneck but the equipment hasn’t caught up. They aren’t leaving the wire and such, it’s logistics, nothing to get too worked up over. It’s a matter of getting the Conex’s in theater.

old shoe

The Blue Star Service flag may be displayed by any person that has a family member on active duty in a time of war or hostilities.

from the Blue Star Mothers Website:

The Service flag is an official banner authorized by the Department of Defense for display by families who have members serving in the Armed Forces during any period of war or hostilities the United States may be engaged in for the duration of such hostilities.

http://web.memberclicks.com/mc/page.do?sitePageId=64171&orgId=bsma

old shoe

Barbara Kerr said: “My son is currently deployed to Afghanistan. Would he have taken part in what happened at Abu Gharib? I don’t know. I’m not sure he knows either.”

As a Navy vet with 27 years of commissioned service, I can tell you unequivocally that most of us would not consider such behavior neither legal nor ethical. Servicemembers are held accountable for their activities. While I obviously don’t know your son, I seriously doubt your son would have taken part in it. As a professional Soldier who has served 15 years, he has been steeped in the ethos that forbids torture or unethical treatment. The Uniform Code of Military Justice is quite exacting on this issue. There are always a few who transgress; smart leadership watches, takes action to head off problems, and holds Soldiers and their Leaders acountable.