Joni Ernst, the “combat veteran”
Senator Joni Ernst commanded a company of transportation folks in Iraq in 2003-2004 and now she’s being criticized by those people on the other side of the aisle because she calls herself a “combat veteran”. From Raw Story;
The newly elected Republican lawmaker defended her military service record after a Huffington Post article pointed out that she never came under fire while serving in Iraq and Kuwait more than a decade ago, reported the Omaha World-Herald.
[…]
The report pointed out that Ernst frequently reminded voters and now constituents of her combat veteran status, and she has not corrected others when they suggest she led troops into battle.
“I am very proud of my service and by law I am defined as a combat veteran,” Ernst said. “I have never once claimed that I have a Combat Action Badge. I have never claimed that I have a Purple Heart. What I have claimed is that I have served in a combat zone.”
First of all, the stank-ass hippies at the Huffington Post aren’t the arbiters of who is a combat veteran and who isn’t. This sounds like something I’d read at VoteVets or in an IAVA scorecard. I think that Jessica Lynch might take exception with the Huffington Post that truckdrivers aren’t allowed to call themselves “combat soldiers”.
Several people who thought that I’d agree with them have sent me links to the various stories about Ernst complaining that she’s stealing valor. I disagree, not because she’s a Republican, but because she’s a veteran who served in an area that earned her “imminent danger pay”. If she was claiming honors that she didn’t earn, I’d agree, but she hasn’t.
We go on and on about telling the truth, that all military service is honorable without embellishment. Ernst hasn’t said that she was kicking doors or interrogating prisoners or anything else. She has said that it was the luck of the draw that her unit didn’t encounter enemy soldiers or improvised explosives. That’s true, not everyone spends their 20 years in the service in constant danger and in contact with our enemies. She was in Iraq and she led the troops in her command in a way that they were able to complete their mission without any injuries and that is an accomplishment in itself.
Yes, we’ve disagreed with veterans in politics but without criticizing their actual service, and I’m not going to begin now. Even the Huffinton Post admits that Ernst and her troops performed admirably;
Senator Ernst calls herself a combat veteran at every turn — on her Senate web page, in campaign debates, and in her stump speeches. She can say this because she served in a combat zone.
And it’s technically true. She was company commander of the Iowa National Guard’s 1168th Transportation Company during its tour of active duty in Kuwait and southern Iraq, from February 2003 to April 2004. But the unit was never in a firefight, or for that matter attacked at all; it delivered supplies, and later, guarded the front gate and ran perimeter patrol at their home base outside Kuwait City, Camp Arifjan.
The HuffPo finds a veteran who will criticize her, but they haven’t bothered talking to anyone who will defend her. This is not my surprised expression.
Thanks to Bobo for the link to Raw Story
ADDED: I just talked to TSO and he says that the reporter at HuffPo, Andrew Reinbach, interviewed him for an hour for that article and TSO pretty much said what I wrote – but HuffPo didn’t use even a minute of the interview with him. Gee, I wonder why?
Category: Media
Looking at this from the prospective of a peace time veteran I look at this argument and shake my head.
For background I joined after high school graduation which was a year after the Vietnam conflict had ended. By the grace of God during my enlistment in the Infantry I was not required to go into a combat zone. Farthest from the US was New Zealand and Korea.
The argument about whether the Senator who freely joined into the military and was deployed to a combat zone can be called a combat veteran is in a word insane. Is it because through the luck of the draw she wasn’t in a firefight or is it her MOS and her location. If it is the former it was the gods will get over it, if it is the later I have a question, what would you call the members of the 14 Quartermaster Detachment in the first Gulf War?
I find the whole hairsplitting logic of whether she is REALLY a combat veteran if she didn’t directly take fire about like hearing the folks debate whether or not evolution is real “because it is only a theory”.
[…] Joni Ernst, the “combat veteran” […]
Maybe the real issue here is not Sen. Ernst’s status as a veteran, but rather HuffPo’s completely intentional effort to muddy the waters by questioning someone who actually served in a war zone but wasn’t as designated infantry, or whatever.
This is definitely hussypo blowing smoke up someone’s backside, but since Brie-brie Williams has been suspended by NBC (they are in the middle of Big $$$$ negotiations with Comcast) for 6 months (and may, in my opinion, get fired) they are going to look quite stupid stirring this pot.
Hussypo is not much better than a gossip columnist in most of its ‘stories’. They are going to look more than stupid over this before too long.
Its not a designation.
Its a lifestyle.
Just an observation.
And as for the former LTC’s service/record; no issue here. I consider her an honorable woman.
[…] Colorado Dems Block Efforts To Ban “Welfare For Weed” This Ain’t Hell: Joni Ernst, The “Combat Veteran” Weasel Zippers: Military Brass Demand Apology From NBC For Segment Smearing Chris Kyle Megan […]
[…] a Lefty, who belongs to the ProgLefty movement that seeks to define who is a veteran. Then the columnist really nails […]