Hey Sir, Where’s Your Medal of Honor?

| July 6, 2009

ironcross

I don’t get an email like that every day. Naturally it came with a link to an article.

Der Spiegle has the story of Germany’s newest version of the Iron Cross called “The Cross of Honor for Bravery”.

The medal is the fifth and highest distinction in the Bundeswehr. According to the decree that created it, the new cross honors “exceptionally courageous deeds” that go beyond what is expected “within the framework of the performance of duty.”

The story is mostly about the medal itself and the controversy it caused by its resemblance to the old Iron Cross.

What caught my attention was this phrase, “exceptionally courageous deeds” that go beyond what is expected. This struck me because all of my sources say that the German contingent are pretty much “Fobbits” who are not allowed to do anything remotely close to fighting.

At the very end of the article we finally learn the heroic actions that these four soldiers did to earn the highest distinction in the German Army.

The four soldiers that were honored on Monday were witness to a suicide attack by Taliban militants on Oct. 20, 2008 southwest of Kunduz. Two German soldiers were killed and two wounded in the attack. Five Afghan children were killed, one injured. Although the German’s armored vehicle was on fire and munitions were exploding, the four soldiers, aged 28 to 33, rushed to the scene to try to help.

Okay let me try to get my brain wrapped around this one. You are a soldier in a war zone and an explosion happens and several people are killed or wounded and rushing to the scene to render aid is “beyond what is expected”?

Don’t get wrong, this probably rates a three day pass or an extra beer ration but the highest medal in the whole frigging army?

In fact, not rushing to the scene could easily be cause for charges of dereliction of duty or cowardice.

Note to the German Army; this is the kind of action that deserves this kind of medal. Meet SSG Erich Phillips:

Mortar Platoon Sergeant for Chosen Company, 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment (Airborne), was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross Sept. 15, 2008 in Vicenza, Italy, for his actions at Ranch House in Nuristan Province, Afghanistan Aug. 22, 2007.

Phillips initially directed fire from the mortar pit, then led its defense — holding off more than a dozen insurgents who had breached the perimeter with a combination of small-arms fire and grenades. Then he and Sgt. Kyle Dirkinitis, a medic, rushed out to defend an isolated guard post. Phillips halted another enemy advance with more grenades and fire.

Dirkinitis — who would eventually receive the Bronze Star with “V” device — was then wounded in the chest. Phillips dragged him to safety and directed another soldier to treat his injury while rejoining the fight. Strafing runs by the A-10 and machine-gun and mortar fire by the Chosen Company soldiers forced the enemy to abandon their positions.

Phillips then led a team that retook part of the perimeter. He then dragged another wounded soldier from a destroyed guard tower and directed the evacuation of wounded.

And even that DID NOT rate the highest award in the American army.

If you start giving away medals, people will stop earning them.

Category: Politics

12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
OldCavLt

Richthofen is spinning in his grave.

AW1 Tim

Germany should bring back the Iron Cross. It wasn’t a Nazi medal.

VTWoody

No offense, but how arrogant for a US soldier to question the validity of a medal. If Germany has decided that these 4 men deserve an honor then so be it. I mean if any country is guilty of throwing medals out for no reason, its the USA. Look at the chest candy out there today. Besides the MOH and the Marine Corps, everyone is ridiculously decorated. A Bronze Star for being an E-6 in a combat zone??? Saw a whole Batallion get them. I decked my squad leader, went to a field grade article 15 and still got a good conduct medal. Little ribbons and shiny trinkets are what awards in the military have basically been turned into.

COB6 Wrote: A whole Battalion, eh? Woody, you’re an idiot and a liar. This is not an IVAW site; perhaps you should try to find one. Congrats on that Good Conduct Medal (if you actually got it).

AW1 Tim

He was ineligible for a Good Conduct Medal if he had received an article 15 during that enlistment. If, in fact, he has a Good Conduct medal for the years during which he received an article 15, then he needs to be stripped of it, as the award was in error.

I suggest that the proper military authorities be informed of the situation, and have an investigation opened as to whether “Woody” is wearing a decoration to which he is not entitled, either by intent, or by error.

respects,

VTWoody

Well COB6, ask your buddy TSO. It was his battalion too.

And yes, I did get the award. No I do not wear it.

Anon

VT, perhaps you fail to recognize the importance of the Valor device on the bronze star?

B Woodman

To get back to the original post. . .
It sounds as if the New and Improved EU Germans are going the way of the Surrender Monkey French, handing out medals for just showing up at the scene of a battle (even if it is afterwards).

TSO

Woody- Who got them?
I didn’t even get a good conduct medal much less any others. All awards were done based on promixity to the TOC at BN as far as I can see.

However, Woody definitely not a IVAW guy.

TSO

Holy crap, just talked to Woody who filled me in on some stuff I didn’t know.

The Bronze Stars were given to all E6’s and above apparently. That seems in line with my battalion, and the reason I still get a case of the monkey ass when discussing the leadership thereof.

Frankly Opinionated

And a Fireman should get a medal for actually showing up at a fire, a cop for showing up at a hostage standoff, and the plumber, he actually goes into a bathroom with a stopped up toilet. Proper medals are earned, not “given”. And VT Woody? Got a GCM after an Art. 15? I guess the times they are a changin’. Wouldn’t have happened in the 101st Abn in the 60’s for sure.
nuf sed

JB

Was wondering, since you are at ASU, if you knew that SSG, now SFC Erich Phillips lived in the Tucson area before joining the Army in 2001. He went to Marana High School.

Anonymous

anyone can get a bronze star….its if it has a “v” device (Bronze Star Medal with Valor) Which you can only get for combat actions. Just plain Bronze stars can be awarded for pretty much anything. BTW SFC PHIL is a BAMF