Book Review: The Comfort Station

| March 14, 2017

Anyone who has young kids knows that your book reading goes to damn near nil.  But I’m making an exception and writing and posting this book review because Kelly Crigger is a long time friend of the blog, and it’s worth your time to read it.

Once in a while a book comes along that’s educational and entertaining. Kelly Crigger’s The Comfort Station is that book. The culmination of twelve years of work, this is Crigger’s eighth book, but first foray into fiction and he wrote a winner. Crigger (a retired Lieutenant Colonel) first learned about the hot button issue of comfort women, who were abducted and forced into prostitution for the Japanese Army, while stationed in Korea in 2004 and decided to write about it.

The Comfort Station starts out in 1942 during the Japanese occupation of Korea when tens of thousands of young women were mysteriously disappearing from the peninsula. Our heroine, a teenage farm girl named Ki-Hwa, ignores her parents and brothers pleas to stay in hiding and befriends a Japanese officer. Before she knows it, she’s forced into sexual slavery as a comfort woman for the Japanese Army and is shipped to the South Pacific island fortress of Rabaul to be the mistress of a legendary Cavalry Officer.

“I wanted to shed light on the issue of comfort women,” Crigger says, “But there had to be a good fictional storyline too. So the main premise here is, what happens when you take the wrong girl? Up to 200,000 women were abducted from Korea. There had to be several with enough strength and defiance within them to fight back.”

That singular storyline is compelling enough, but what Crigger does that makes this a great read is take real history and bend it just a little so it’s believable and captivating. Rabaul was a massive Japanese garrison that MacArthur simply bombed the everloving crap out of and then went around, cutting it off and letting it die from inside. Including the comfort stations.

From the book’s summary: “Allied Forces pummel the island in preparation for an inevitable invasion. Paranoia grips the garrison when Admiral Yamamoto, the architect of Pearl Harbor, is killed in an Allied ambush shortly after leaving Rabaul and fingers are pointed in every direction. Within this chaos, life for Ki-Hwa and hundreds of others in the comfort stations is survival of the fittest. Once a farm girl afraid of her own shadow, Ki-Hwa discovers people are callous, sadistic, and deceitful and must find the strength to resist the mighty and unforgiving Empire along with her one true friend. But when an imposter threatens to unravel the group’s carefully laid plans she is forced to make an impossible choice between guaranteed security and a shaky promise of freedom.”

Just like the main character who decides to fight back, Crigger also developed an intriguing Japanese Imperial Soldier who questions the authority of the Empire and decides to do something about it. “I can’t imagine everyone had blind devotion to the Emperor so I decided to ask the question ‘what happens when you defy him?’ So then I crossed the paths of these two rebels and this story fell out.”

The Comfort Station is a great page turner with a few massive twists that leave you wanting more. The best books provide the reader with an escape from reality and The Comfort Station does just that.

Category: Book Review

12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ALVO

Dare I say “FIRST” ……in line….at the “Comfort Station”…..? No sloppy seconds today for meeeeeeeeee!

Poetrooper

ALVO, your review may be lacking in culture and refinement, but it is succinct…

desert

Yamamoto died in a plane crash!

11B-Mailclerk

Yup. His plane crashed into a metric crap-ton of .50 BMG slugs.

Then the ground swatted it pretty good.

Dustoff

Mrs. Dustoff’s uncle was taken by the Japanese during WW2 and put in a labor camp (and never returned). On our visits back to South Korea I’ve found that anti Japanese sentiment is still high. Even today the argument over naming the East Sea/Sea of Japan has been taken all the way to the UN.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmF2o3NEUd4

just some feller

In my experience, the older generation enjoyed speaking with me in Japanese if they could; a few older people hated to hear Japanese.

It was the born-after-1945 college-aged kids who showed strong anti-Japanese sentiment.

But my experiencedx may differ from others.

Silentium Est Aureum

Young kids, older kids, same is same, TSO.

Seems like if it isn’t a technical manual I hardly pick it up much anymore.

Will try to make an exception here, however.

CWORet

Apparently free with a Kindle Unlimited subscription. (If you read the reviews, there are some soilers) https://www.amazon.com/Comfort-Station-Kelly-Crigger/dp/0991238257

CWORet

and some spoilers, along with those soilers…

The Other Whitey

Sounds interesting, if not exactly my usual literary fare. I’ll give it a shot.

As for the history behind it, well…there’s a lot to like about Japan. But to say that the japs in WWII were fucking animals would be to give them an undeserved compliment.

Graybeard

And be a slander of innocently-copulating animals world-wide.

But they stand as an example of what happens when an extremist, fanatical group gets power – much like we just avoided from Hildabeast & Co.

Al Johnson

The description is partially correct “Take real history and bend it a little.” It actually bends it alot. The Comfort Women system was investigated by the US Military, UK Military, and Dutch Government (NIEF) both during the war and immediately afterward for both propaganda, intelligence, and war crimes. The results from all reports (there are multiple) is that it was a contract prostitute system, the women were well paid (more than some field grade officers), could refuse service for any reason, and living conditions were better than most other contractors and almost all military units. Specifically in Rabaul, there is a diary of former PoWs (one had to slave for the Comfort Women chopping ice for their drinks) that tells of the Korean Comfort Women taunting the dying PoWs from Australia (and some coastwatchers from the US). The last thing the PoWs heard was the sexual taunting of the women on the balcony. But it is not Kriegger’s fault. I believe he fell honestly into the trap that many Americans have regarding the Comfort Women. Most outside the loop are unaware that the House of Sharing and Chon Dae Hyop (that promotes the issue) are connected with North Korea heavily, have had leaders arrested for fraud and spying charges, and are now bringing in former PLA (the genocidal Chinese Army) women to pose as the latest group they take on tour. The issue has a clear historiography, that actually started with a Japanese communist wrote a book he later admitted was fiction about hunting girls in Cheju Do. The Koreans were still alive then (it was the 1980s) and all denounced his claims. Turns out he was never even in the military or Cheju Do. Then it was a cause celebre from various communist groups in South Korea and Japan because the KCIA had just resumed a working relationship wtih Japanese intelligence over the abduction cases of some 1000 teenagers from Japan by North Korea in the 70s and 80s. Japan was bringing this up to the Untied Nations when suddenly the accusation that 200,000 women were kidnapped appeared. This… Read more »