The special rights crowd files a law suit

| October 27, 2011

Yeah, they just wanted to overturn Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell so they could serve, because service was the most importnt thing to them (Stars & Stripes link);

A group of eight gay servicemembers sued the federal government Thursday for military and veterans benefits for their same-sex spouses, arguing that ignoring their marriages amounts to discrimination.

The move comes a little more than a month after the end of the military’s controversial “don’t ask, don’t tell” law, which for 18 years prohibited gay troops from publicly acknowledging their sexual orientation.

I guess there no potential for abuse of the system if they get their way, right?

“This case is about one thing … justice for gay and lesbian servicemembers and their families,” said Aubrey Sarvis, executive director of the Servicemembers Legal Defense

Oh, so it’s not about service…it’s about justice now, huh? And by justice they mean fairness. Or ramming a deviant lifestyle down the collective throat of the military.

Category: Military issues

295 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
insipid

Well, to be fair, Doc, Sparky is giving as much as he’s getting. But yeah, the back and forth is, to me, a bit much. Yo mama jokes would be much more entertaining:

How bout, Yo mama is so fat that when she went to the movies, she sat next to everyone!

NHSparky

Yo momma so fat when she walks across the room the fuckin RADIO skips.

NHSparky

No, the whole issue with “gay rights” has never, will never be about “equal”. It’s about “special.”

Try and understand that difference, won’t you?

insipid

I understand the ARGUMENT, Sparky, i don’t agree with it. And wow, you packed a hell of a lot of condescension in two sentences. I’m impressed.

Redacted1775

OG interjects and proves she still has no idea what’s going on right now…..it’s a good title, you should stick with it.

eric

You all are missing the big picture. Being gay IS genetic, and allowing them to marry instead of hiding it and being w/ the opposite sex will slowly kill off the gay gene. They’ll breed themselves away, so let’s allow it!

Doc Bailey

Yo mama is so fat she sat on a rainbow and made skittles.

You mama is so dumb she kept saying ARE NOT to R2

Your mama is so dumb the thought a quarterback was a refund

Your mama is so fat she has her own zip code

Your mama is such a skank its easier to list the people she HASN’T slept with

that do it for you insiped?

insipid

The argument is that it’s natural, not that it’s an inherited trait. Plus i think you mean that they’ll fail to breed and thus go away. Anyway, it’s a stupid argument. But if that’s what it takes to convince folks, go ahead and make it.

insipid

Pretty good, Doc. How bout, Yo mama is so stupid she tries to put her m & m’s in alphabetical order?

Redacted1775

Yo mama so fat she bent down to take a shit and a bus fell out.

Just thought i’d add my 2 cents. 😉

Semper Fag

I am currently serving gay US Marine, and while I’ve encountered a lot of homophobia in my time, I’m shocked and disgusted by what I see here.

insipid

@ Semper I’m shocked and disgusted by what I see here.

Oh, it was my idea to do the yo mama jokes to lighten the tension. Oh, wait, you were talking about the homophobia?

Well, i agree with you there. But really do we need the F word in your name? It sounds like i’m older than you since my service ended over 20 years ago so i guess it bothers me more, but stil….

Doc Bailey

@211 ever heard of “suck it up and drive on”?

Yo mamma is so fat when she sits around the house, she really sits AROUND the house

Redacted1775

Then you know, as most active duty Marines know, exactly what’s changed in the fleet since DADT has been repealed. That’s right. NOTHING. It’s business as usual. I imagine it’s the same everywhere else, because no one really cares.

insipid

And when gay marriage and all our other rights are granted it will be less than a to-do as well. Massachussetts has had it legal for a number of years now and it still has the lowest divorce rate in the union.

That and Yo mama is so stupid she put paper on the television and called it paper view

Redacted1775

Yo mama so fat she got smaller people in orbit around her.

Semper Fag

I like to use the F word because it takes a line of attack away from idiotic shitheads like DOC BAILEY and his ilk.

“Suck it up and drive on” Fuck you. Your a little homophobic worm. I’d love to meet you somewhere and kick the living shit out of you. Then you could go home and tell all your buddies that you got the snot stomped out of you by a homo. You little fucking bitch. Who the fuck are you?

Doc Bailey

I would like to throw out that I think its a less of a genetic thing than a sociological inclination. Especially in the case of women, whose sexuality has always been a bit more “fluid”.

The “gay community” tends to make most society nervous and anxious, because rather than being asked to be left in peace which MOST people would respect. In most of the “pride” parades it is as in your face as possible. Forgetting that “Tolerance” doesn’t mean acceptance, it means you put up with something. Its kinda like someone sticking a finger an inch from your eye and saying “I’m not touching you you can’t be offended”. That gets pretty fucking old quick.

Redacted1775

Not saying I agree with either side, just saying I don’t care. If you know your job and do it well, I couldn’t possibly give a shit less if you go home at night and attempt fornication with a fuckin watermelon. Now if your sexual orientation is the most important thing in your life and it’s the only thing that defines you, then I say you need to re-examine your priorities. A few twits have come to mind, like that AF puke that came out to his parents on youtube. They should slap the taste out of his mouth when he comes home.

Doc Bailey

hey fag, I’m not afraid of gays. I don’t give a shit if your gay. I DON’T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT IT. I don’t give a shit who you do on your own time, or how you do it but when you’re at work your there to work dammit.

Who am I? Well I’m a Combat Medic from San Diego Ca, with two combat tours to Iraq. If your identity is so easily brused I suggest you joined the wrong fucking service. Ranger the Fuck Up!

King

217, Thanks for your service. Watch out though, Doc is deadly with kali sticks and nunchucks.

219, why should his parents slap the taste out of him? You make no fucking sense. You’re an idiot.

Redacted1775

like I said king, you’re a dweeb, that is all. the little puke exploited his parents infront of an internet audience for his own personal gain.

NHSparky

King–cause if someone slapped the shit outta you, they’d have to bury you in a thimble.

Redacted1775

I mean good lord man I know the internet is a step up for you from your normal finger painting and pop up picture books, but try to keep up would ya?

insipid

I use the name insipid for much the same reason, Semper. But I also think it’s funny…. I don’t sense a lot of humor coming from you. Generally that works a little better than calling someone a “fucking bitch”.

I understand insulting someone over the internet as long as it’s funny or cute or at least trying to be, but just calling people names is something i honestly don’t get.

For whatever it’s worth, you and doc, and probably Obama Girl could probably kick the shit out of me. I don’t profess to be a tough guy. But i do think my arguments are good and if i can’t win based on that i don’t see how threats are going to sway anyone.

Basically it just leads to mindless pissing contests about what i could do to you or what you really are. Garuntee if this goes on someone will postulate you’re something else. Which you’ll deny and then postulate something about them. It’s predictable and silly.

Dino S.

Yes, it is pretty disgusting and pathetic to read some of these comments. Gay bashing doesn’t make you more of a man 2-17 Air Cav or Old Trooper. Real men don’t have to attack gays to prove their masculinity. What effect will legalizing gay marriages have on you guys anyway? I guess we all need to have a convient scapegoat to blame all our problems on.

NHSparky

Oh, thtop it, Dino, you thilly boyth!

King

Yeah he really gained a lot from that, didn’t he? If some straight guy had youtubed himself telling his parents that they were going to be grandparents, or that he was getting married, should his parents slap the shit out of him too?

Yeah Sparky, keep coming with the stellar insults, you fucking pussy. All you can deal in is half assed insults and unwarranted condescension. You’re a fucking joke. A 99 afqt score and you can’t come up with a coherent line of reasoning as to why you feel way gays want “special”, not “equal” rights when Insip has asked you so civilly to provide him with one. You can’t do this because you’re a fucking idiot. Your brain might be wired well enough for you to be good at the nuke shit you do, but the other parts of it probably couldn’t even fill a thimble.

King

You’re just a fucking bully sparky, who’s propped up by his little circle jerk friends on here. Deep down you’re a sopping wet vag. Keep making stupid wisecracks at insip, dino, and semper. You’re a twat, and a pea brained one at that.

Redacted1775

#228 As usual, this dude just doesnt get it. Is becoming grandparents or conventional marraige a major issue in the media right now? No. Clearly fucking not. Was DADT recently repealed? Yes. It clearly fucking was. Is it a major issue in the media? Yet again, yes it clearly fucking is. I connected the dots for you, if you can’t figure it out form there then you’re obviously the biggest fucking retard on the planet. A four letter SN explains alot. Back to your fingerpainting and pop up picture books son.

insipid

@Doc Baily The “gay community” tends to make most society nervous and anxious, because rather than being asked to be left in peace which MOST people would respect. In most of the “pride” parades it is as in your face as possible. Forgetting that “Tolerance” doesn’t mean acceptance, it means you put up with something. Its kinda like someone sticking a finger an inch from your eye and saying “I’m not touching you you can’t be offended”. That gets pretty fucking old quick.

That’s bullshit. I don’t see any straight restorative clinics, i don’t see anyone preaching that straights shouldn’t discuss their sex lives in public or show straight kisses on screen.

Homosexuality is not choosen, but even if it were so what? Religion can be choosen as well. We still respect peoples rights to have it.

If a person has a sincere religious belief, they can apply for — and are usually granted — exemptions from generally applicable and neutral laws. Employers, too, are required to accommodate people’s religious beliefs even if this means exempting them from generally applicable, neutral rules in the workplace.

When interracial couples fought for the right to marry each other, were they asking for equal rights or special rights? They wanted the same rights as other couples, but conservatives insisted they really wanted special rights. After all, no one was allowed to marry members of another race, so all were treated equally. Right?

It is a profound insult to tell people that their desire to enjoy the same basic rights as other Americans is really a desire to have “special” rights unavailable to others. It’s possible that some Christians do consider housing, jobs, and medical care to be “unusual demands” — at least, when it comes to gays. While it’s still legal in most states to fire someone JUST for being gay, you cannot say we’re arguing for “special” rights.

Semper Fag

Insipid- you don’t strike me as the kind of person who really needs an ass kicking. I can’t say the same for most of the “people” here.

King

Yeah nice reasoning, shitheel. To a gay service member the DADT appeal was probably about as momentous an occassion as a straight person getting married or having a kid. But I guess he shouldn’t be allowed to share his joy on youtube, because it’s a fucking current event. Please consider suicide you fucking imbecile, you’re too stupid to breed.

Redacted1775

Dude, you’re dumb as a fuckin bag of hammers. Like I said earlier nothings changed because no one really cares. Shit man get your head out of your ass. I actually feel bad for you the way you show up here and consistently embarass yourself.

NHSparky

Poor king, it’s like I was telling your mother the other night after I left the quarter on her nightstand–and she even gave me the change back this time–that you simply weren’t beaten enough as a child.

What would sail right over your pointy fucking worthless little head is that it is not, never was, about “equal”. Gays want to shove their sexuality in our faces. It defines them. Sadly for them, while sexuality is a part of all of us, we do not let it DEFINE us.

Now this is the part where I’m gonna start using words like, “concept”, “equality”, and well, “words”, and just to make it fair, I’ll type slow so you can keep up while you mouth the words as you read my post.

The whole argument that skin color is the same is sexual orientation and should be somehow treated like that is, quite frankly, a bullshit argument. Whether nature or nurture makes someone gay is irrelevant, because one’s sexuality not something overtly obvious in most cases, as opposed to one’s melatonin level. But see, the militant gays don’t see it like that.

There are some fears of homosexuals, some not rational, some totally legitimate. The STD rate, for starters, is a very legit reason some aren’t all that fond of the gay community. Then we get into the marriage issue. Now, this may come as a huge shock to you, but marriage was a RELIGIOUS institution long before it was a LEGAL one. Even in hetero marriages, spousal privilege varies widely from state to state. There are those who feel it is an affront to their religious and moral beliefs, that recognizing same-sex marriage, as opposed to civil unions or domestic partnerships, is in fact an attack on their mores, and in some cases, they’d be right.

Such is a brief statement, so now back to you, fuckwad.

King

Really? Nothing’s changed? Tell that a gay soldier who now doesn’t have to fear an early discharge if someone happens to find out who they prefer to sleep with. Tell that to someone who no longer has to hide who they are for fear of losing their job. Tell that to someone who can now go to their chain of command if they’re being harassed by other soldiers who suspect they’re gay without worrying that it would lead to them being punished worse than their harasser. The fact that you can’t even comprehend that this might be a big deal for some people shows just how dumb you are.

NHSparky

Newsflash, genius–something like 75-80 percent of the discharges under DADT were from people trying to avoid deployment.

Now what excuse are they gonna use?

insipid

Here’s a quote from Plessy v. Ferguson that sounds familiar:

If the two races are to meet upon terms of social equality, it must be the result of natural affinities, a mutual appreciation of each other’s merits and a voluntary consent of individuals. As was said by the Court of Appeals of New York in People v. Gallagher, 93 N.Y. 438, 448, “this end can neither be accomplished nor promoted by laws which conflict with the general sentiment of the community upon whom they are designed to operate. When the government, therefore, has secured to each of its citizens equal rights before the law and equal opportunities for improvement and progress, it has accomplished the end for which it was organized and performed all of the functions respecting social advantages with which it is endowed.” Legislation is powerless to eradicate racial instincts or to abolish distinctions based upon physical differences, and the attempt to do so can only result in accentuating the difficulties of the present situation. If the civil and political rights of both races be equal one cannot be inferior to the other civilly [*552] or politically. If one race be inferior to the other socially, the Constitution of the United States cannot put them upon the same plane.

Plessy v. Ferguson, 163 U.S. 537, 551-552 (U.S. 1896)

That and Yo mama so ugly when she joined an ugly contest, they said “Sorry, no professionals.”

Doc Bailey

King there you go with a physicality thing again. I thought we got over that point when I described what my workouts are like. Seriously dude. You realize that threatening to beat someone up over the internet is like threatening someone to a no holds bard slap fight.

Insipid, Why would I WANT to kick your ass? you have given me no provocation, reason or even really an inkling that you want to throw down. I respect that you are keeping this civil (sort of) I disagree totally with what you’re saying but. . .I respect that you have the Cahones to come on here and say such.

Hey Semper Fag, you know WHY you get “homophobic” responses (for the record again: Disliking something is not the same as being afraid of it), I’ll tell you. You wear the fact you’re gay like a god damned badge of honor. Its not. I love having sex with women. Who cares? No one is going to throw a strait pride parade. You run around screaming “I’M GAY I’M GAY I’M GAY” probably with some uber gay dance to go with it then turn around to the guys and say “don’t ya just love me?”. News flash: IT DOESN’T WORK LIKE THAT! you know in a man’s world your feeling mean jack and shit. you’re not “brave” for having sex. Maybe if it was with a super skank with the gonaherpasyphilAIDS and you HAD to do it to prevent a war or something, but even then. . . Here’s my advise to you. STFU. Stop trying to out yourself every chance you get, and prove yourself actually ya know competent at your job. Then you MIGHT recieve less “homophobia”

Redacted1775

It’s not a big deal. Most people where i’m at didnt even realize it was repealed until two weeks after the fact. Like I said, bag of hammers.

Doc Bailey

“dumb as a bag of fucking hamsters”

Thanks Redacted, I’m going to have to use that!

insipid

That’s true, i saw two people do that during basic, and they weren’t even gay. Another reason why it’s a good thing that it is repealed!

Redacted1775

Hammers doc, hammers!!! Hamsters have more cognitive thoughts than this king dickface here…wouldnt want to drag them down.

insipid

Well, if you’re a hamster and you’re stuck in a bag with other hamsters, why not fuck? Seems like a smart thing to do to me.

That and Yo mama so stupid she went to the orthodontist to get a blue tooth

Doc Bailey

oh come on Hamsters!

Redacted1775

Yo mama so skanky she keeps a bag of ice between her legs to keep the crabs fresh.

Doc Bailey

your mama’s so fat even Chuck Norris couldn’t lift her!

insipid

But Doc, look at the argument in Plessy, it’s the SAME argument, if blacks just stay silent and quiet people will eventually give them their rights if they dont kick up a fuss. It didn’t work for blacks, it won’t work for gays.

Also why is it that the majority thinks that the minority shouldn’t fight for their rights? I mean when the tea party fought at all the townhalls i thought they had the right, even though i think they were wrong. If we think we’re right, why should we be quiet. We have the right not to remain silent.

And really, if you would deny us rights simply because you think we’re too loud, how petty does that make you?

And Yo mama so stupid she thought the credit crunch was a new chocolate bar

King

Has it ever occurred to you Sparky that throughout history gay people have pretty much been defined by their sexuality by non-gays? Has it ever occurred to you that maybe gays band together in their own communities because it’s safer for them, because they’ve been historically persecuted? And has it occurred to you yet, that the more militant types became militant as a way of saying “fuck you” to people who presumed to tell them what they can and can’t do with other consenting adults? Do you really believe that most gays actually want to flaunt their sexuality in your face and tell you about whose dick they’re sucking, or whether they’re the top or the bottom? Seriously, that’s what you think they want? As opposed to, I don’t know, maybe being able to admit who they are and have it be left alone after that? Do you really think that Adam and Steve want to suck each other’s dicks in the men’s room and force you to deal with it? I’m pretty sure people pairing up with each other in monogamous bonds was a human phenomenon long before religion reared its head. But since you want to use religion and the state in your argument let’s go with that. If I get (hetero) married down at the courthouse without any clergy members overseeing the ceremony, is that not an affront to religious groups based solely on the fact that it’s purely secular and that god is not involved in it? Couldn’t they argue that I did that out of a denial of god’s existence? Wouldn’t that offend them? Why should I give fuck if it does? I’m not in the business of giving a shit what a particular religious group thinks of me and my marriage. But since marriage belongs in the realm of the religious, shouldn’t my arrangement with my special lady be called something else, like a Civil Union, or a Domestic Partnership? More to the point, why should the state give a fuck whether or not some religious people get offended by any of their policies,… Read more »

Doc Bailey

actually they did get their rights by being compotent at their jobs. See: 54th Mass, 9th, 10th Cav, 24th Infantry Regiment, Tuskegee Airmen. They got their rights, and changed attitudes by being the best at their job. At Pelileui a black Marine Ammo company preformed many acts of heroism to help out fellow marines. It did not matter what the color of their skin they were Marines.

There is always this *erroneous* belief that rights come from the top down. That laws will make reality. But it never works like that. Respect is not, and CAN NOT be given. It is earned. who would you respect more a Black soldier, or a Soldier that happens to be black. The differences can be subtle but very distinct.